KUALA LUMPUR (Feb 7): Shares of MyEG Services Bhd closed 26.7% lower at 70 sen on Tuesday — the lowest since November 2020 — following news reports that all immigration services and processes will revert to the Immigration Department by 2025, including those being managed by third parties such as MyEG.
Earlier, the counter gapped down on market opening to 65.5 sen as it fell 30 sen or 31.4%. At market close, MyEG saw its market value reduced by almost RM2 billion to RM5.21 billion.
It was the most active stock on Bursa Malaysia with 1.02 billion shares traded.
New Straits Times on Monday quoted Immigration Department Director General Datuk Seri Khairul Dzaimee Daud as saying that the Home Ministry had set aside RM900 million for the roll-out of the National Integrated Immigration System (NIISe) in two years, and that the new system is expected to be a "game changer" that would improve the department's efficiency and customer experience.
NIISe, which is currently developed by Iris Corp Bhd, will replace the current Malaysian Immigration System (myIMMS) that the department has been using for about 13 years. It will converge all immigration transactions, including passport renewals, visa applications, applications and renewals of permits for foreign workers
In a filing with Bursa Malaysia, MyEG clarified that it has not held any meeting with Putrajaya on converging all immigration transactions under the NIISe.
“The board of directors of the company wishes to clarify that the company has not held any meeting with either the Ministry of Home Affairs or the Immigration Department of Malaysia on the intention to converge all immigration transactions under the NIISe,” it stressed.
Short-selling suspended
Shortly after market opening, Bursa suspended short-selling of the stock for the rest of the day under proprietary day trading (PDT) and intraday short selling (IDSS), after the stock dropped more than 15 sen or 15% from its reference price.
“Short-selling under PDT and IDSS will only be activated the following trading day, on Wednesday, at 8.30am,” the stock exchange regulator said in a filing.
Amid the heavy selling pressure, MyEG’s co-founder and managing director Wong Thean Soon bought five million shares or a 0.067% stake for RM3.69 million or a 73.8 sen apiece, bringing his direct and indirect stakes in the company to 12.4% and 17.27% respectively. The company itself also bought back two million shares or a 0.03% stake on the open market at RM1.44 million or 71.5 sen each.
Iris Corp, on the other hand, gapped up to 13.5 sen from 12.5 sen at last Friday's close, and jumped to as high as 19 sen. The counter closed at 16.5 sen on Tuesday. It had been trading below 16.5 sen after June 7, 2022.
Affin Hwang Investment Bank said in a note on Tuesday that the news is negative for investor sentiment, and may affect MyEG's long-term earnings trajectory. It downgraded the stock to "hold" from "buy", and cut its 12-month target price (TP) for the stock to 93 sen from RM1.23.
It estimated that immigration-related services contribute to 40%-50% of MyEG's revenue.
"These immigration-related services include the renewal of foreign workers’ work permits (10%-15% of total revenue) and other ancillary and commercial services, such as renewal of foreign workers’ insurance and foreign worker job matching (30%-35%). In May 2020, the government extended MyEG’s contract for the provision of online renewal of foreign workers’ work permits for three years till May 2023. The loss of services, if reverted to the Immigration Department as planned, may impair MyEG’s long-term revenue (2025 and beyond) by about 20%."
‘There could be changes to deployment of NIISe project'
Affin Hwang IB, however, believes that the full deployment of NIISe by 2025 is "likely a tall order", following conversations it had with several industry players and the financial results of the project's key contractor, Iris Corp.
"As such, there could be changes in the development and deployment of NIISe, which may: i) affect the timeline in returning of foreign workers’ work permit renewal services to the Immigration Department; and ii) present new business opportunities for industry players, including MyEG," it said.
Nevertheless, the news and policy risks are expected to weaken investors’ interest in MyEG, considering the material revenue contribution from its immigration-related businesses.
"On the other hand, MyEG’s steady 2022-24 earnings outlook, stable revenue from the road-transport businesses, exciting new business opportunities (the Road Transport Department's e-testing system, and blockchain initiatives), and potential business opportunities from NIISe-related works should help support its share price," it added.
Hence, while it maintained its earnings forecast for the stock, it lowered the valuation multiple to 19 times its estimated 2023 price-earnings ratio (PER) — from 25 times — due to heightened policy risks.
"Key upside risks to our view are favourable changes in the Immigration Department’s outsourcing policy, better-than-expected financial performance, strong pickup in its blockchain business, and securing new contracts to develop and deploy e-government services. Downside risks to our view are unfavourable changes in the government policies, lower-than-expected financial performance, and weak adoption of MyEG’s Zetrix blockchain," it added.
MIDF Research shared the same view, noting that the policy risks would likely deter investors from MyEG considering that the company’s potential net income could be lowered by almost 20% after 2025
Nevertheless, the research house likewise believes that MyEG's stable earnings forecast for 2022-2023, steady sales from its road transport businesses, and potential new business opportunities from the NIISe and initiatives such as the Road Transport Department's e-testing system and blockchain projects, could support MyEG’s share price.
To account for the elevated policy risks, MIDF has lowered its target price for MyEG to RM1 from RM1.23, but kept the stock on 'buy'.