Monday 23 Nov 2026
main news image

KUALA LUMPUR (Sept 30): The High Court has allowed Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's application for determination of preliminary issues before the commencement of a sexual assault civil case brought against him by his former aide Muhammed Yusoff Rawther.

In his latest application linked to the suit, Anwar wants several issues concerning Yusoff's movements and presence at Anwar's private residence on the day of the alleged assault — Oct 2, 2018 — to be decided even before the trial commences.

In allowing the application on Wednesday, High Court judge Datuk Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah Raja Mohzan said that the questions raised were fit to be determined as preliminary issues and would save substantial time and cost.

The judge said that if the issues are determined in Yusoff's favour, then the trial would then be narrowed to whether the assault happened. He added that if the court decides in Anwar's favour, then that would be the end of Yusoff's claim.

"The plaintiff (Yusoff) must first have been present at the defendant's (Anwar) Segambut residence on Oct 2, 2018, before the alleged sexual assault and/or trespass to the person could have taken place in the study.

"This being the case, if the preliminary issues are answered in the defendant's favour, the plaintiff’s claim will come to an end.

"On the other hand, if they are answered in the plaintiff's favour, the findings will be final and binding, and the continuing trial will be confined to the alleged sexual assault and/or trespass to person," he said in reading out his grounds, which took over an hour and half.

Anwar wants a few questions to be determined:

  • Whether Anwar’s former private secretary, Shukri Saad, actually instructed Yusoff to personally deliver the copy of a speech to Anwar’s then Bukit Segambut Dalam residence on Oct 2, 2018;
  • Whether Yusoff had travelled with Anwar’s former security personnel, Norafee Ahmad @ Dekdi, from Anwar’s office in Petaling Jaya, to the Bukit Segambut residence around 3pm on Oct 2, 2018;
  • Whether the alleged meeting between Yusoff and Anwar at the residence took place at all on that date.

Anwar wants these issues to be decided either via affidavit or remote proceedings.

Judge stresses that justice must be seen to be done, evidence must be given orally subject to cross-examination

Raja Ahmad however was of the view that the preliminary issues cannot be determined by way of affidavits, as requested by Anwar, but have to be carried out via oral evidence where the witnesses will be subject to cross-examination.

"Regarding the conduct of the trial, it shall be conducted by way of Zoom and shall remain open to the public in the manner that I have outlined [...]," he said.

He added that the press should be allowed to cover the proceedings as, citing case law, "open justice is a fundamental principle in many legal systems, rooted in the idea that justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done".

"For my part, I would respectfully suggest that members of the press be permitted to attend and report on the proceedings. The close representatives of each party should also be permitted to attend.

"In this regard, I must emphasise that, in my view, the principle of open justice does not require the Zoom hearing to be open to an unlimited audience. Just as a physical courtroom can only accommodate a limited number of members of the public, a remote hearing need not admit thousands of people before the requirements of open justice are met.

"The presence of the press would be sufficient to serve the principle of open justice while allowing the trial to be conducted in an orderly manner.”

The judge added that the remote proceedings would also accommodate Yusoff to attend the proceedings as he is currently in the UK, seeking asylum. He has also surrendered his passport to the UK authorities.

In this case, Anwar is represented by former Bar president Christopher Leong, while lawyer Rafique Rashid Ali is appearing for Yusoff.

Yusoff had filed his civil suit in July 2021, where he claimed that following his police report on the incident, he was accused of plotting to bring down Anwar and damage the PKR president's political career. He claims that the alleged sexual assault and the accusation have affected his mental health.

The matter will be heard before a new judge, as Raja Ahmad is scheduled to be transferred to the Ipoh High Court on Nov 1.

Edited ByAniza Damis
      Print
      Text Size
      Share