
PUTRAJAYA (Sept 10): MCT Bhd (now known as Avaland Bhd) (KL:AVALAND) and two of its subsidiaries are continuously barred from having commercial development at the Lakefront Villa in Cyberjaya.
This follows MCT and its subsidiaries Lakefront Residence Sdn Bhd, and Timeless Hectares Sdn Bhd, having failed to obtain leave (permission) from the Federal Court to have their appeals be heard in a majority decision on Wednesday.
A three-member apex court bench, led by Datuk Nordin Hassan with fellow judges Tan Sri Ahmad Terrirudin Mohd Salleh and Datuk Che Mohd Ruzima Mohd Ghazali, sat on the bench on Wednesday.
Nordin said they arrived at a split decision in not granting leave to the company. However, the bench did not disclose which judge was in the majority or minority.
With Wednesday’s decision, the Court of Appeal decision on April 10, which upholds the High Court’s decision to bar any commercial development at the site, stands.
The three-companies were also ordered to pay RM50,000 total costs to the 46 house buyers who had challenged the development.
The homebuyers of Lakefront Villa were represented by Ravindran Shanmuganathan of Messrs Sreenavasan Young and Ameer Hazeem.
Ravindran confirmed the outcome when contacted by The Edge on Thursday morning.
Datuk Lim Chee Wee Messrs Lim Chee Wee Partnership, and Justin Voon, Tan Ko Xin, and Cherry Huang You You from Messrs Justin Voon Chooi and Ving Advocates and Solicitors, appeared for MCT/Avaland and subsidiaries.
They had posed 11 questions of law to be decided should leave have been gained.
In civil cases as the apex court, leave (permission) has to first be gained based on novel questions of law before the merits of an appeal can be heard.
Last April, a three-member Court of Appeal bench led by Datuk Supang Lian had dismissed the three companies’ appeal.
In reading the bench’s broad grounds, the third member of the bench, Datin Evrol Mariette Peters, had ruled that Lakefront Residence was in breach of its contract with the home buyers, citing the preamble to the SPA as the basis for the court’s decision.
The preamble had in unequivocal terms stipulated that the developer would develop the land as a housing development known as Lakefront Villa @ Cyberjaya, the judge added.
The developer had cited the existence of a planning permission to convert some residential units into commercial properties as the basis for their change in plan.
However, Evrol said the change in plans was a clear and admitted departure from the contractual promise.
“The existence of a planning permission does not excuse a breach of contract. To hold otherwise would mean that a developer could promise one thing to a home buyer, obtain a planning amendment subsequently, and then claim immunity from its contractual promises,” she said.
Evrol said that while the Sepang Municipal Council had earlier rejected the commercial development in 2021, the Selangor Appeals Board had granted it permission, and the judge noted that as the permission was granted under the Town and Country Planning Act 1976, this would allow the developer to proceed with commercial construction.
“[However, this permission] cannot override the developer’s private contractual obligations owed to the home buyers, [which] states otherwise,” the judge said in dismissing the companies’ appeal.