
PUTRAJAYA (April 10): A three-member Court of Appeal bench has affirmed a High Court decision in 2023, that bars developer Lakefront Residence Sdn Bhd, Timeless Hectares Sdn Bhd and MCT Bhd (now known as Avaland Bhd) from having commercial development at the Lakefront Villa in Cyberjaya.
Lakefront Residences and Timeless Hectares are subsidiaries of MCT Consortium Bhd.
The three-member bench was led by Judge Datuk Supang Lian, and the others were Datuk Dr Shahnaz Sulaiman and Datin Evrol Mariette Peters on Thursday.
Evrol who read the broad grounds in the unanimous decision ruled Lakefront Residence was in breach of contract to the home buyers in citing the preamble to the SPAs as the basis for the court’s decision.
This follows the preamble had in unequivocal terms stipulated the developer would develop the land as a housing development known as Lakefront Villa @ Cyberjaya, the judge added.
The developer cited the existence of a planning permission to convert some residential units into commercial properties as basis for their change in plan.
However, Evrol said the change in plans was clear and admitted departure from the contractual promise.
“The existence of a planning permission does not excuse a breach of contract. To hold otherwise would mean that a developer could promise one thing to a home buyer, obtain a planning amendment subsequently, and then claim immunity from its contractual promises,” she said.
Evrol said while the Sepang Municipal Council had earlier rejected the commercial development in 2021, the Selangor Appeals Board had granted permission and she noted while permission was granted under the Town and Country Planning Act 1976, would allow the developer to proceed with commercial construction.
“However, it could not override the developer’s private contractual obligations owed to the home buyers that stated otherwise,” the judge added.
Following the dismissal of the developers appeal, they were ordered to pay RM50,000 costs to the home buyers.
The home buyers were represented by Ravindran Shanmuganathan of Messrs Sreenavasan Young and Ameer Hazeem while Justin Voon and Tan Ko Xin of Messrs Justin Voon Chooi and Ving Advocates and Solicitors appeared for the developers.
Ravindran, when contacted by The Edge, confirmed the outcome of the court case.
The bench also dismissed the developers’ argument that the home buyers do not have locus standi (legal standing) to initiate the action as they claimed it should be done by the joint management body (JMB).
Evrol ruled that the home buyer had an individual contract with the developer, and it was not necessary for the JMB to be involved.
In 2023, the High Court granted an injunction sought by the Lakefront Villa @ Cyberjaya home buyers to bar the developer and its subsidiaries from carrying out commercial development on the said property.
Then Judicial Commissioner (JC) Leong Wai Hong further granted a declaration that the Lakefront Villa @ Cyberjaya project is to be a housing/residential development project comprising 110 units and that the area is to be used for residential purposes only.
The house buyers contended that the defendants had made false representations to them that the “maiden project” would be a “gated and guarded development with only 110 exclusive luxury villas surrounding a panoramic lake".
They further alleged that the developer had breached the sales and purchase agreement (SPAs) they entered with the company between 2014 and 2020. The commercial project was rejected by the local council in 2020. This decision was then overturned by the Selangor Appeal Board in 2021, resulting in its revival.
Leong in his 68-page judgement quoted a Malay proverb Kata itu kota, which means a promise made must be honoured, or the English equivalent “A man’s word is his bond”.
He said as the developer and its partners made representations on their websites, newsletters, brochures and in the show model in its showroom, the court assumed the house buyers only had these to go on when making their purchases.
The court said although there were disclaimers on the brochures, it ruled that these cannot be relied on as they were in too fine a print.
“A disclaimer that cannot be read by the normal eyes has no valid legal effect,” Leong ruled, adding that MCT had acted on behalf or in complicity with the two other defendants to make the representations and that the disclaimers have no legal effect.