Friday 20 Nov 2026
main news image

PUTRAJAYA (Nov 20): A three-member Court of Appeal bench on Friday deferred its verdict on the appeal by Sacred Heart Canossian Convent to get a replacement land title to the plot they had occupied since 1905 from the Melaka Land Registrar and two others.

Judge Datuk Azizul Azmi Adnan, who led the bench comprising Datuk Faizah Jamaluddin and Datuk Aliza Sulaiman, said the court needed time before delivering its full decision.

The bench then set Dec 3 for case management for further developments in the case.

The Mother Superior of the Daughters of Charity of the Canossion Institute (Malaya) and the Agent of the Commission for the Administration of the estates of the Portuguese mission in China and Singapore had named three state land officials in a suit over the failure to recognise and register the appellants’ legal and/or beneficial interest on Lot 6 at Bandar Hilir.

The High Court had last year, ruled that the land belongs to the state, as the missionaries had failed to prove any pre-existing legal or beneficial ownership interest. The convent school on Lot 6 also contains a residence for nuns and a chapel.

The missionary school, represented by lawyers Datuk Dr Cyrus Das, Datuk Joy Appukuttan and Benjamin John Dawson, argued that the sisters had been occupying the land with a Dutch Title Deed (DTD), and that the land belonged to the appellants and not the state.

They further argued that the respondents —  Melaka's director of land titles, director of land and mines, and registrar of land titles — had admitted the land belonged to the Portuguese convent and they cannot retract the admission.

“As the respondents who possess all the relevant land records and expertise on the subject, they could not have made a mistake to say the land belongs to the state. Their assertion that the word Portuguese convent on the DTD record refers to usage and not ownership cannot be accepted.

“This follows that there is overwhelming historical evidence supporting our client’s claim of ownership to Lot 6,” they said.

The lawyers said there were no competing claims to the property and it is the respondents’ duty to prepare the replacement title for Lot 6, in line with the National Land Code.

“The authorities cannot rely on their own omission to deny our client’s claim for a replacement title to Lot 6,” they added.

The lawyers further said the authorities' consideration on technicalities and procedural issues should be avoided and not be allowed to triumph over constitutional rights to the ownership of the title, as it violates Article 13 of the   Federal Constittution on the right to property

Issue started in 2014

The appellants' predicament began in 2014, when their lawyers wrote to the authorities to have their ownership of Lot 6 registered under the National Land Code (Penang and Malacca Titles) Act 1963

On June 3, the registrar of land titles acknowledged that records showed the owner of Lot 6 to be the Portuguese convent.

However, the registrar requested that the appellants produce the original DTD.

The appellants stated that the DTD was lost when a priest named Father Coroado, who held the document, was captured by the Japanese and died some time in 1944.

Despite this, the nuns produced various documents to show ownership of Lot 6.

The lawyers claimed that director of Land and Mines Department could have processed the application for a replacement to the DTD, and the absence of the colonial-era document was immaterial given the Land Office records recognising ownership.

On March 8, 2022, the authorities informed the lawyers that they do not have the authority to register ownership of Lot 6 under the NLC

This was because at the time, there was no director or deputy director of land titles to carry out the task, and the director of the Land and Mines Department suggested they bring the action to court.

The nuns did so, but the Melaka High Court ruled last year that the convent did not own the land.

On Aug 6, the Court of Appeal allowed the appellants to adduce further evidence, comprising contemporaneous official correspondence between the land owner of Lot 6 and the Melaka municipality in 1936, as kept by the National Archives.

Authorities say pre-existing interests must be proven

Melaka state legal adviser Datuk Khairul Azreem Mamat, who appeared with senior federal counsel Anis Wahidah Mohamaed and Muhammad Idzwan Ishak, said the court has to decide whether the appellants had a pre-existing interest on the land.

Khairul Azreem cited Section 5 of the NLC stipulating that all land is owned by the state government and that the Portuguese Convent is on government land.

He added that they should have approached the authorities when the NLC came into force, following the loss of title.

“If the land title is lost it has to be reverted back to the state and they have to claim their rights by filling a 'form 4E' which empowers the authorities to investigate,” Anis Wahidah added.

Azizul then pointed out the appellants claimed they had not received the form and that even the state authorities had suggested that they go to court.

Khairul Azreem said the authorities can only write a request to the King for the vacant post of director of land titles to be filled. The position remains vacant.

Edited BySyed Azahedi
      Print
      Text Size
      Share