
KUALA LUMPUR (Nov 19): Lawyers for two former M Jets International Sdn Bhd directors suggested in the High Court on Thursday that logistics provider MMAG Holdings Bhd and its executives engineered a corporate scheme to oust the duo in 2023.
The former directors, Gunasekar Mariappan and Philip Phang Kin Ming, are locked in a legal dispute with MMAG Holdings, M Jets, and seven others.
The dispute arises from a joint venture formed in November 2020 to acquire and transform M Jets — then a private jet charter company — into an air cargo operator. Under the deal, MMAG Holdings was to own 80% of M Jets and invest RM46 million, while Gunasekar and Phang’s JT Aerotech Solutions Sdn Bhd (JTAS) would hold 20% and invest RM10 million.
On Thursday, witness and second defendant Kenny Khow Chuan Wah, who is a former executive director of MMAG Holdings, denied the allegation there was a plot to remove Gunasekar and Phang.
Gunasekar’s lawyer Alex De Silva had suggested to Khow that MMAG hatched a plan around September 2022 to block expenditure, push M Jets into the red and eventually oust Gunasekar and Phang.
The lawyer played for the court a recording of a purported meeting where Khow is discussing this with someone.
De Silva suggested to Khow that MMAG Holdings issued a notice of default on March 10, 2023. On March 16, three minority shareholders and directors of JTAS — R Shanmugananthan, Anton Alex Schubert and M Saysu — accepted MMAG's default notice and agreed to remove Gunasekar and Phang as directors.
De Silva also suggested to Khow that MMAG Holdings offered the three JTAS directors a RM5 million bribe to turn on Gunasekar and Phang.
Khow disagreed.
MMAG Holdings accepted JTAS's replacement directors the next day on March 17, despite having never met them. Gunasekar and Phang were terminated in April 2023.
When De Silva accused MMAG Holding of "playing" on the board majority to eliminate the plaintiffs, Khow countered that the directors held a valid board majority and denied any improper manoeuvring.
MMAG Holdings is suing Gunasekar and Phang for RM23.17 million for alleged breaches of fiduciary duties in M Jets.
Both men then counter-sued nine parties in July 2023 for RM49.85 million, alleging they had conspired to harm their investments in M Jets. Among the nine is businessman Victor Chin Boon Leong, who is entangled in allegations of a corporate mafia that purportedly involves rogue businessmen and Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission officers coercing others into giving up their companies.
Gunasekar and Phang claim they were responsible for running M Jets, including securing aircraft leases, renewing licences and managing fuel arrangements.
Both of them allege that issues arose when additional funding of about RM20 million for expansion in late 2021 and early 2022 was not provided. The duo then claim Chin and MMAG Holdings reversed their position on the venture, leading to operational disruption, estimated losses of about RM16 million and failure to scale the business.
De Silva's cross-examination of Khow then challenged MMAG Holding’s withholding of funds to M Jets.
Gunsekar's lawyer pointed out that audited accounts recorded a net loss of approximately RM40.27 million for the financial year ending March 31, but M Jets was experiencing rapid top-line growth. Following the acquisition of a fourth aircraft, M Jets' annual revenue surged more than 2.5 times from RM61 million to RM164 million, while losses almost halved.
Hourly revenue generation also expanded almost fourfold between June 2021 and December 2022.
Khow defended his conduct, testifying that he had only withheld approval for unbudgeted capital expenditure but not routine operational expenses.
De Silva suggested that because M Jets was doing well, Chin and MMAG Holdings including Khow had used their connections to initiate MACC raids on M Jets. Khow denies this allegation.
The trial before Justice Leong Wai Hong continues Friday, with Khow to be re-examined by his lawyers, Wong Kah Hui and Jung Yi.