
KUALA LUMPUR (Nov 19): The Genting group has succeeded in halting Sycal Bhd's proposed construction of hotels and commercial buildings on plots adjacent to its resort and hotel.
The plaintiffs — Genting Highlands Bhd, Genting Malaysia Bhd (KL:GENM) and its subsidiary First World Hotels and Resorts Sdn Bhd — claimed such a move would affect the structure of the First World Hotel, which it claims is the world’s largest, and roads leading to the resort.
The outcome follows an April 30 High Court decision granting the Genting group a quia timet injunction, which is sought to prevent anticipated harm before it occurs.
Genting applied for the order to protect its existing property in Genting Highlands, owned by First World Hotels and Resorts, which comprises the hotel, Sky Avenue, Arena of Stars, Genting International Convention Centre and an indoor theme park.
Genting Malaysia is a listed subsidiary of Genting Bhd (KL:GENTING), while Genting Highlands operates as part of the broader Genting group structure under Genting. Sycal is a subsidiary of listed Sycal Ventures Bhd (KL:SYCAL).
High Court judge Datuk Aliza Sulaiman (now a Court of Appeal judge) ordered the defendants to pay RM2 million in costs and RM243,800 in general damages for the slope damage at the mountain resort caused by the proposed project by Sycal and its subsidiary.
Aliza also declared the earthworks and slope modifications unlawful without valid permissions.
Hence, the court ordered specific slope support restoration and restrained further illegal works to be done by the defendants.
The defendants are appealing against part of Aliza’s decision. The judge issued a 275-page grounds of judgement on Oct 29, which was uploaded to the e-Judgement website on Nov 16, and the matter is now pending before the Court of Appeal.
Genting, together with Genting Malaysia and First World Hotels and Resorts, filed the legal action in February 2020. The defendants named are GM Aero Support Sdn Bhd, Sycal Bhd, Lau Yee Sum (Perunding Jutera), Perunding Rekacekap Sdn Bhd, Lee Yong Chiew (YC Lee Architect) and Zahiruddin Zainal (practising as Town Planning Services).
Genting alleges that Sycal’s development, which it claims is 100 metres from First World Hotel, could affect slope stability and amounts to nuisance and trespass. It also alleges negligence, claiming that the purportedly illegal earthworks and slope cutting could affect its properties.
GM Aero and Sycal plan to build 10 blocks on their land northeast of First World Hotel. The blocks will include hotels and commercial suites ranging from 27 to 56 storeys, as well as parking.
The defendants submitted the proposed project to the Bentong Municipal Council, the local planning authority.
Genting Malaysia issued a letter to GM Aero notifying it that the works carried out posed a grave threat to the safety and stability of First World Hotel, the surrounding land, roads and other properties.
In 2020, Genting appealed to the Pahang Planning Appeal Board (PAB) against the approval of the project. However, on April 7, 2021, the PAB struck out the appeals filed by Genting and Genting Malaysia over the Sycal project.
Genting alleges that the project violated the Town and Country Planning Act 1974 and the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974.
The trial lasted 76 days over six years, with various expert witnesses testifying. Six witnesses testified for Genting and nine for the defendants.
The defendants claimed the suit was an abuse of the court process and a deliberate attempt to stop development and eliminate competitors at the hillside resort.
Aliza granted Genting’s application for declarations that the earthworks were unlawful and breached the permissions granted by the local authority.
The court also granted injunctive relief restraining further slope modifications, excavations and the use of support structures.
Emphasising that the safety risks and illegal construction justified preventive measures, the judge also ordered the mandatory restoration of the affected slope.
Genting was represented by The Eng Lay, Andy Gan Kok Jin, Lucas Chong Wan Jien, Bryan Yau Jun Ting and Luqman Afiq Kamarudin of Messrs Cheah Teh Su while the defendants were represented by B Thangaraj, Sanjay Mohan, Wong Li-Wei, Tan Jia Shen and Faye Lee Chin of Messrs Sanjay Mohan/Thangaraj & Associates.