
PUTRAJAYA (Nov 17): The Court of Appeal (CoA) on Tuesday dismissed an application to stay the winding-up order against Genneva Sdn Bhd, the company behind a massive gold investment scam, saying a delay in the liquidation process would hinder victims from recovering their losses.
In a unanimous decision, a three-member bench led by Datuk Zaini Mazlan ruled that the application by company director Chin Wai Leong did not establish any special circumstances to warrant a stay.
The court said the interests of creditors, many of whom had waited years to recover their investments, must be taken into account.
“In our judgment, the interest of the creditors, many of whom are individuals who have waited years to recover their investments, must also be considered. A stay would prevent the liquidator from carrying out his functions of liquidation and further delay the determination and payment of the creditors’ claims,” Zaini said.
Chin had argued that the liquidation and distribution of the company’s assets, including approximately 28.3kg of gold bars, before the company's appeal against the winding-up order is heard would render the bid meaningless.
Zaini said the liquidator must administer the company’s assets and liabilities and deal with creditors’ claims in accordance with the law.
“The fact that these steps may take place before the appeal is disposed of does not, in our opinion, constitute special circumstances,” he said.
Zaini, who sat with Datuk Leonard David Shim and Datuk Seri Latifah Haji Tahar, added that even if Chin succeeded in his main appeal, the company would still be required to settle its liabilities.
On Sept 30, the Shah Alam High Court ordered Genneva’s winding up. Judicial Commissioner Wan Fadhilah Nor Wan Idris found that the company, which had been convicted of unlawful deposit-taking, had lost its foundation. It had ceased operations for many years and no longer held the licences and permits required to resume its original business.
The court also confirmed interim liquidator Wong Weng Foo’s appointment to oversee the liquidation.
Ng Wan Yee, who holds 750,000 shares in Genneva, had filed the winding-up petition in August 2024 to prevent other directors from removing more than RM21 million in assets that were released from seizure under anti-money laundering laws.
The move followed a Sessions Court order on June 28, 2024, that revoked the seizure orders on millions of ringgit and the gold bars.
In her petition, Wan Yee said there was a “high likelihood” that the company’s directors or other relevant parties would dissipate the assets for personal benefit rather than use them to settle claims by thousands of investors.
She also alleged that some directors had attempted to “siphon monies” under the guise of paying professional fees.
Another creditor, Liew Chio Chuan, a 25% shareholder in Genneva, opposed the petition and challenged Wong’s appointment. He argued that there had been “material non-disclosure” by Wan Yee and that there was “no real danger” of the assets being dissipated before a formal hearing.
A key issue in the dispute was the movement of funds shortly before the winding-up petition was filed.
Records showed that, following the lifting of the seizure orders, Genneva’s directors authorised the transfer of RM11,659,661.20 from the company’s Maybank and Public Bank accounts to a stakeholder account held by its long-time solicitors, Messrs Gooi & Azura.
In today’s judgment, Zaini said the liquidator had raised concerns over the sum and that the validity of the transaction needed to be investigated.
“The liquidator must be allowed to discharge his statutory duties, including investigating the transactions and proceeding with any recovery,” he said.
Genneva and its top executives were found guilty in August 2020 of illegally accepting deposits worth tens of millions of ringgit. The company was fined RM450 million, while several executives were jailed and fined hundreds of millions of ringgit.
Former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad launched Genneva’s “syariah-compliant” gold trading scheme on Dec 15, 2010.
Matthew Thomas Philip appeared for Chin, while Alvin Tang represented the respondents. Afdhilani Jusoh appeared for the creditors, and S. Ravenesan represented the liquidator.
Matthew and Ravenesan confirmed the outcome when contacted.