
KUALA LUMPUR (Nov 17): The High Court in Johor Bahru has found SIPP Rail Sdn Bhd, Syarikat Pembenaan Yeoh Tiong Lay Sdn Bhd (YTL Construction) and the secretary general of the Transport Ministry negligent over the permanent loss of road frontage suffered by a property developer following the construction of a railway bridge in Labis, Johor.
Judicial Commissioner Dr Noradura Hamzah, in a judgement dated Oct 16, 2026, ordered the three defendants to pay Bintang-Bintang Development Sdn Bhd RM15,828 in special damages for the loss of its direct frontage along Federal Road 1.
The dispute centred on Lot 3057 in Bandar Labis, Segamat, a 5,794-sq-m commercial plot owned by Bintang-Bintang.
The developer had obtained planning approvals to build eight semi-detached houses and a bungalow on the land, which had 37.269 metres of frontage along Federal Road 1, also known as Jalan Yong Peng or Jalan Labis.
However, the construction of Road Over Bridge 8 (ROB 8), part of the Gemas-Johor Bahru Electrified Double Track Project (EDTP), obstructed the property's direct road access by raising the main road onto a flyover embankment in front of the site.
In her judgement sighted by The Edge, Noradura said although the railway electrification project was authorised by statute, its execution had failed to adequately consider the property rights of neighbouring landowners.
She noted that dedicated side access had been provided for other neighbouring properties, while Bintang-Bintang's land was bypassed.
"Those who carry a bridge across the frontage of a neighbouring lot must foresee that the lot will lose its frontage. These defendants did foresee it," she said.
The court also noted that the Public Works Department (JKR) and project engineers knew that Bintang-Bintang had obtained planning permission, but proceeded with the project without accommodating the approval because physical construction on the land had yet to begin.
Noradura said the fact that the land was vacant did not justify depriving its owner of its frontage rights.
She also noted that local planning authorities had not been briefed on the bridge alignment when the developer's initial planning approvals were granted.
However, the court dismissed Bintang-Bintang's claim for total loss of access, ruling that an alternative route via Jalan Pejabat Kerajaan was physically available.
Noradura said the developer had repeatedly been advised by project engineers and municipal authorities, dating back to August 2019, to submit a fresh application to the relevant Transport Ministry agency for the alternative access, but failed to do so.
"A landowner who is advised how to bring a deprivation to an end, and who declines, cannot recover for the continuance of that deprivation," she said.
The court also dismissed the developer's trespass claim against all four defendants, including AAY Construction Sdn Bhd, an earthworks subcontractor engaged by the SIPP-YTL joint venture.
Noradura said physical encroachments during the 2019 construction works had already been resolved through a full and final settlement of RM24,000 paid by the joint venture in June 2019. Subsequent allegations of trespass were not proven against specific defendants.
The court also declined to award aggravated and exemplary damages sought by Bintang-Bintang, limiting the special damages to land premium and surveyor expenses.
Under the court order, SIPP Rail, YTL Construction and the Transport Ministry secretary general were each ordered to pay RM40,000 in legal costs to Bintang-Bintang, totalling RM120,000.
In a separate order, Bintang-Bintang was directed to pay RM40,000 in costs to AAY Construction.
The defendants included: SIPP Rail and YTL Construction, which carried out the railway works through the unincorporated SIPP-YTL joint venture; the Transport Ministry secretary general, sued in his official capacity as the designated project director overseeing ROB 8; and AAY Construction, which undertook site clearance and embankment earthworks as part of the AAY-Umpanjaya joint venture.
Senior federal counsel Haji Mohammad Al-Saifi Haji Hashim, who represented the Transport Ministry secretary general, confirmed to The Edge that the ministry, SIPP Rail and YTL Construction had filed appeals at the Court of Appeal last week.