
This article first appeared in Forum, The Edge Malaysia Weekly on November 16, 2026 - November 22, 2026
"Are you not entertained?” With more goals, more attacking play, more big games, and even “lovable underdog” stories, it is a fair question to ask at the halfway point of the UEFA Champions League group phase. But, unlike the crowd questioned by Emperor Maximus (Russell Crowe) in Gladiator, football fans wish the combat was a little more, well, gladiatorial.
The lack of jeopardy is glaring. One of the boasts of the Swiss-style format, now in its third season, is that it serves up more major clashes than the previous mini leagues did. Yes, the draw produced potential blockbusters between Bayern Munich and Arsenal, Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) and Barcelona, and Atletico Madrid and Bayern. But in none of these games was the “block” ever in danger of being “busted”.
The clubs did not even field their strongest sides, and although the games were watchable with spectacular goals, there was a conspicuous lack of edge. The harsh truth is they did not really matter. A team can afford to lose five of its eight matches and still qualify for the next stage, as Benfica did last year. The season before, PSG lost three times and drew once to finish 15th in the group. Then they lost a leg in two of their two-legged knock-out ties before going on to win the trophy. As FourFourTwo puts it, the new format is “more forgiving than a Las Vegas priest”.
Calling the first stage a “league” grossly inflates its status. The 36 participants do not play each other twice, home and away, as is the norm. Here, they meet only a sample of different opponents — some tougher than others — so the rankings aren’t a true reflection of performances.
Despite this supposed “short cut”, like the previous format, the tournament takes a long time to get going. Of its 189-match total, no less than 144 are in the first phase, yet only 12 of the 36 teams are eliminated. All the top eight finishers earn is exemption from the next two-legged play-off phase. These matches are for teams that finished between ninth and 24th, with the winners meeting the top eight “seeds” in the Round of 16.
Critics say the tortuous process is deliberately designed to make more money, with 64 more games, while offering (four) more entrants a shot at glory. But crucially, it makes it difficult for the big boys to drop out early. All things to all men? Something had to give, and what is being sacrificed is the very essence of sport and the reason we watch in the first place — the jeopardy.
After 2½ campaigns, which have had a certain novelty value and one or two welcome new faces, the format is coming under closer scrutiny. And to all but hardcore fans, like its previous iteration, it still isn’t compulsive viewing until the knock-out phase. It is the difference between waking up to catch it live or recording it.
To be fair, something had to be done with the tired old format. Staid, predictable and littered with dead rubbers, it only rarely produced a memorable game before the business end. But you do not have to be a cynic to see that its replacement is simply kowtowing to the wishes of the big clubs while making a token gesture to the smaller ones.
The big boys had to be kept onside. Twelve of them — including six from the English Premier League (EPL) — were disillusioned, and greedy enough, to form the breakaway Super League in 2021, where they hoped to play each other all the time. Although it was killed off in 72 hours, UEFA and the rest of football remain wary of what super-rich owners motivated only by profit may cook up next. Ironically, this compromise has given them a sobering glimpse of what a disaster it would have been.
So, for the foreseeable future, the current arrangement looks here to stay. In an industry that has never heard of “less is more”, UEFA is mightily relieved it has found a formula that suits both big and small clubs. And the knock-out rounds should still produce enough drama to make the journey worthwhile.
But for the purist, it is another ominous sign that football is moving away from its “people’s game” roots to the entertainment industry. Almost every aspect, from the pre-game fireworks to the in-game stoppages, is becoming part of a grander “show”. Never more so than in the biggest game of all, the World Cup final, where half-time took half an hour to accommodate a pop concert. As esteemed Argentinian coach Marcelo Bielsa said: “What made this game the best game in the world at the time is not prioritised today.”
And tomorrow, it could be further down the pecking order, according to a global survey by Ticketmaster. The world’s leading ticket sales company revealed that in places as diverse as the UK, Mexico, the US and the Middle East, people want more bang for their buck. Almost 25% of 15,000 fans seek “immersive, entertainment-led experiences in sport, from music and stadium production to sports tourism and seamless in-venue technology.”
This smacks very much of Gen Z, to whom results matter less than the occasion, unlike traditional fans who would rather win a dull game one-nil than lose a thriller 4-3. But to others, the score is becoming a mere sideline on a day out where they can meet friends, have a meal, hear music, sit in comfort and maybe even get a sauna or a swim. All this is available in those super stadiums we saw at the World Cup and is being incorporated outside the US too.
It is the way that Americans watch sport, and no coincidence that they are finally taking a serious interest in the world game. Half the EPL clubs are owned by Americans, and there are celebrities, too, in the Championship with Wrexham’s Hollywood actors Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney. While football fans abhor the stop-start of VAR interventions and hydration breaks, the less committed welcome them. Time for a soda, anyone?
Nothing could be further from the quasi-religious ritual of the traditional supporters. Flocking faithfully to the ground, standing in sardine-like “pews”, bellowing the club “hymns” as the time-honoured ritual unfolds, rain or shine. Then the trudge home in either delirium or dismay, weekend made or ruined often by the width of a post.
Football is unique in having billions of followers around the world, many of whom observe this routine on a regular basis. Besides being the most-watched sport on the planet, it is the most talked-about and most passionately debated. Nothing else comes close. As the historian Tom Holland has said, “Elite football is now the most popular pastime the world has ever known.” Football’s own historian David Goldblatt adds: “Football is truly the most extraordinary lens on society.”
The final word has to go to Mauricio Pochettino, who, as US national coach, has a front-row seat in the American “entertainment industry”. He told the award-winning Overlap podcast: “Football is special because it’s not entertainment; it’s competitive. We’re now forcing this unbelievable sport to become entertainment. I’m seeing in the US, American football, basketball, hockey, it’s entertainment. Football is not that.”
A game of football is not an event; it is a match and does not need decorations. But it must remain competitive. If not, like the gladiators, the game, as we know it, will die.
Bob Holmes is a long-time sportswriter specialising in football
Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.
P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's App Store and Android's Google Play.