Thursday 19 Nov 2026
main news image

This article first appeared in Forum, The Edge Malaysia Weekly on November 16, 2026 - November 22, 2026

After our recent article titled “No Better Time To Substitute Exports Of Intermediate Goods” was published (The Edge, Issue 1650, Oct 26), we received numerous queries around the perennial and mystifying question, “How lah, wei? This one talk easy lah, want to do half-dead one!” (to quote a Manglish speaking commenter).

On the contrary, if you are an Austrian economist of the Friedrich List following, you would already know how (you would need to know 19th century German prose for this). Even the American economic strategist Alexander Hamilton waxed lyrical on the subject of the importance of manufactures for long-term political and economic health. Then, there is the “bespoke” bit, where one has to suit the general guidelines for local circumstances and, of course, modern times and developments.

We put together a grouping of techniques for a paper recently on our website (see the summarised list below), bearing in mind that further tailoring is needed for the country. Here is what we would suggest for Malaysia:

One of the first policy actions that is needed is, indeed, one of the most potent. It was first used by England’s King Edward III (1327-1377), when he temporarily forbade the exportation of raw English wool (to be woven overseas). This protectionist strategy allowed local woollen clothing manufacturers to capture the domestic market and later expand into global exports. Over the long term, this shifted England from an exporter of raw materials to a manufacturing powerhouse, creating the domestic merchant class that would eventually break the Hanseatic League’s monopoly.

This principle of banning imports of manufactured goods (but allowing the imports of raw materials for one’s own manufacturers) is a golden one that holds to this day. Africa is doing exactly the same today and countries there are rapidly building their own industries from scratch, exiting foreign goods and manufacturers that have been there for centuries.

One of the big things that governments realise early on is that, in the world of business, their role is limited. History is replete with examples of state-owned enterprises or government-linked companies going bust. Some of these going under have actually threatened the economies and financial systems of those countries. Instead, the role of governments is best used in supporting such companies, like being the buyer of first manufacture of a new product or innovation, a partner in research and development (where their role is mainly in funding support as well as buying the commercial products that come out of it), identifying value chains to promote and protect and, most basically, to provide the infrastructure that companies so badly need, such as roads, energy, water, ports, airports, rail services and affordable transport.

Here, it is necessary to point out that no nation has ever achieved autarky, a state where a country has become totally self-sufficient. Indeed, in one way or another, countries are interdependent, a state that was so glaringly obvious at the peak of the global trade system that prevailed so recently until a certain orange-haired president of a big country managed to wreck it. Look at his country now. The bottom line is, imposing a blanket import ban is akin to suicide.

Instead, careful consideration should be given to which goods, subsectors and domestic manufacturing value chains could be protected. One key element is to ensure that local manufacturers can offer competitive replacement products or services. The people’s welfare must reign supreme.

Other than a policy ban, another way to protect local industries is through tariffs and its associated non-tariff measures (NTMs). A simple NTM example is for all distance measuring equipment to be measured in units of “setanak nasi” (the time it takes a pot of rice to cook), which is uniquely Malaysian, and not in feet or metres.

Tariffs themselves have been on a quiet battlefield on the trade front, marshalled by the obviously now-defunct World Trade Organization. There was a time when countries engaged in a race to the bottom, trying to cut their own tariffs to zero. Malaysia happily followed this spiralling trend, and its tariffs are currently around 6%. With China’s onslaught of global and cheap production, however, the US not only felt threatened but retaliated by throwing up tariffs of between 25% and 250%. This, then, begs the question whether Malaysia’s shield for its local companies is even adequate. It also raises the question of why a country that champions free trade globally imposes tariffs on foreign imports. The aim of tariffs is to make imported goods so expensive for the local buyer that he chooses to buy a competitive locally made product instead.

In manufacturing itself, government help can and does extend towards reductions of manufacturing costs, such as import duty reductions for raw materials bought by selected industries. At the other extreme, governments can aid local manufacturers by buying in bulk at discounted prices. Such arrangements are sometimes referred to “bounties”, as opposed to “subsidies”, as in the first example. Needless to say, these arrangements are kept under wraps, given the kerfuffle they can generate, to say the least.

Finally, there is the tactic of financial repression, which can manifest itself in three ways:

● Preferential loans from national banks;

● Softer interest rates charged for loans; and

● The country generates foreign exchange rates that are supportive of its exports.

The first two measures have reportedly been used by South Korea, and the last involved quite a few years of effort to ensure that its exchange rate remained “competitive”.

This is the same thing that the US has been accusing China of doing with the yuan recently. Stretching back even further, the Plaza Accord in 1985 was a global attempt to make the very low yen a more competitive currency so other countries’ exports could compete (Japan was the world’s factory then, much like China today), although many would say it is to stop the US dollar from being too strong, but that was due to the many years of high US interest rates then. In the foreign exchange field, there are always two sides to the coin.

How effective is having final goods and brands for a country’s growth? Let’s take a recent example: the great wave of artificial intelligence (AI)-led buying that should have lifted all boats. It did lift boats, but then the differences between economic profiles saw some rise higher than others. Taiwan — famous for its chipmakers such as Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturng Co Ltd (TSMC), MediaTek Inc and United Microelectronics Corp (UMC), to name a few — had a gross domestic product growth of 14.4% in the third quarter of this year, while Malaysia, primarily an intermediate goods assembler, grew at 5.3%.

There it is, then. A suggested plan for reindustrialising Malaysia. The architecture needs to be designed in such a way that would not only meet the strategic objective but cascade down to the lowest levels for maximum effect and participation of the masses. Good luck, Malaysia.


Huzaime Hamid is chairman and CEO of Ingenium Advisors, Malaysia’s financial macroeconomics advisory. His full treatise on a country’s industrialisation and development is in his second book The Formula for National Wealth.

Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.

P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's App Store and Android's Google Play.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share