
KUALA LUMPUR (Nov 16): Lawyers representing the 10 former Negeri Sembilan executive council (exco) members have informed the Seremban High Court that they are working towards an amicable resolution with the state secretary, Datuk Mohd Zafir Ibrahim, and the state government over their expulsion on Sept 20.
Their lead counsel, Datuk Mohd Hafarizam Harun, told judge Roz Mawar Rozain on Monday that this followed a Nov 10 letter from Menteri Besar Datuk Ismail Lasim to the Keeper of the Rulers' Seal, Tan Sri Syed Danial Syed Ahmad.
The letter, which was widely circulated on social media over the weekend, confirmed the withdrawal of a Sept 17 submission to the Conference of Rulers questioning Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir's position as the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan, as well as the exco members’ earlier stance, effectively maintaining the status quo.
Hafarizam initially sought until Thursday for parties to work out. Also representing two of the former excos was Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun.
Datuk Dr Cyrus Das, who appeared with Abdul Rashid Ismail for Zafir, confirmed that certain proposals had been put forward by the plaintiffs and the menteri besar.
"We are giving due consideration to the proposals. The matter should not be prolonged for too long, as there are concerns that circumstances or proposals may change.
"I propose that the matter be adjourned for a short period," Das said.
Counsel Razlan Hadri Zulkifli, who appeared with Marisa Regina Aris Rizal for the Negeri Sembilan government, concurred.
After a short recess to check her diary, Roz Mawar agreed to grant a short adjournment but said Thursday would be too far off, given that parties might make multiple applications.
The court offered Tuesday afternoon or Wednesday morning as alternative dates.
Hafarizam indicated that Tuesday might not be feasible and opted for Wednesday morning.
Roz Mawar subsequently agreed to adjourn the matter until Wednesday morning for the parties to report back on the proposed settlement. If no agreement is reached, she is prepared to hear the preliminary objection raised by the Negeri Sembilan government and Zafir against the 10 former exco members' challenge to their expulsion.
Also present at the proceedings was Negeri Sembilan legal adviser Datuk Muzalmah Mustapha Kamal, who said that lawyers had been in discussions and that due consideration should be given to resolving the matter.
Steven Thiru, David Mathew and Shafrin Halim appeared for the interveners, the Dewan Keadilan dan Undang and its secretary, Raja Norazli Raja Nordin.
Last month, the 10 former Negeri Sembilan exco members filed an originating summons against state secretary Zafir and the state government, challenging the validity of their removal by the Yang di-Pertuan Besar, Tuanku Muhriz.
Tuanku Muhriz dismissed all Negeri Sembilan exco members, except Ismail, in September following their Sept 15 declaration that he was no longer the Ruler of the state.
The palace said the declaration violated the exco members' oath of office.
The former exco members argued that the Negeri Sembilan Constitution requires the Ruler to consult the menteri besar before removing an exco member.
The suit also seeks general, exemplary and aggravated damages, as well as an expedited hearing over the constitutional issues raised.
The exco members have also filed a referral to the Federal Court, which is scheduled to be heard on Dec 16.
Meanwhile, Zafir and the state government have filed a preliminary objection, arguing that the case should have been brought through a judicial review instead of an originating summons.
Read also:
Negeri Sembilan MB confirms withdrawing letter to Rulers, maintaining status quo of Tuanku Muhriz
All deposed Negeri Sembilan excos file suit challenging their expulsion
High Court dismisses Negeri Sembilan excos objection against private lawyers representing state govt, state secretary
Negeri Sembilan excos ask Federal Court if their sacking is constitutional