Wednesday 18 Nov 2026
main news image

Malaysia has a talent problem, but it may not be quite the one employers think. Hays found that 64% of organisations in Malaysia experienced moderate-to-extreme skills shortages, slightly above the 62% recorded across the Asian markets it surveyed.

The instinctive response is familiar: recruit harder, pay more and retain the best people. But what happens after companies find those talented people? Too often, the best specialist eventually gets promoted into management.

It happens across Asia. The outstanding engineer becomes an engineering manager. The strongest relationship banker takes charge of a team. The star salesperson becomes head of sales.

The logic appears impeccable, until it isn't. Being exceptional at doing something and being exceptional at enabling other people to do it are fundamentally different capabilities.

When your best person becomes the bottleneck

The pattern is easy to recognise. Someone becomes the colleague everyone consults when something goes wrong. Senior management trusts them with difficult assignments. Clients ask for them personally. Eventually, they are promoted, yet their behaviour barely changes.

The technology manager remains immersed in technical decisions. The former star analyst still rewrites presentations. The experienced compliance specialist personally resolves every difficult regulatory question.

The title has changed, the professional identity has not. This is the expert trap: the expertise that gets someone promoted can eventually prevent them from becoming an effective manager.

Technical performance is relatively easy to recognise. Who won the client? Who fixed the system? Who delivered the project? Leadership potential is harder to observe.

Can this person develop a struggling colleague? Can they delegate an important assignment without taking it back? Can they manage disagreement and allow somebody to make a mistake and learn from it? Companies can end up rewarding their strongest specialists with jobs requiring quite different skills.

A management problem becomes a business problem

This matters when Asian companies are simultaneously confronting talent shortages and trying to transform their businesses.

In Malaysia, 57% of workers surveyed by Randstad said they would consider leaving an employer if their manager did not support their professional development. 55% said the same if their manager showed insufficient interest in their long-term career progression.

Management is not simply an HR issue, it is a retention issue.

Gallup's research on Indian workplaces reaches a similar conclusion: promotion into management should not automatically be the reward for technical excellence. Companies should instead consider whether someone has the talent and motivation to help other people perform at their best.

A manager who continues solving every difficult problem personally may look indispensable. But gradually, team members begin waiting for approval rather than exercising judgement. Decisions accumulate around one person. The manager becomes busier while the team becomes more dependent.

What looks like dedication becomes a bottleneck.

From expert to enabler

None of this means technical expertise becomes irrelevant after promotion. Managers still need enough knowledge to recognise poor work, challenge assumptions and exercise sound judgement. What changes is the purpose of that knowledge.

Instead of asking, “What can I solve?”, the question becomes: “What can I enable my team to solve?”. That requires a profound change in professional identity.

For years, someone's reputation may have rested on knowing the answer. Suddenly, their job is often to ask the right question. Instead of demonstrating competence by fixing problems personally, they sometimes have to watch somebody else wrestle with them. Their success increasingly appears in other people's achievements.

AI raises the stakes

The Conference Board's research among executives across Japan, China, India, Malaysia, Singapore and the Philippines found Asian business leaders combining investment in AI with growing emphasis on leadership capabilities, including agility, resilience and managing change.

Many analytical tasks through which professionals traditionally demonstrated expertise can increasingly be augmented by technology. This does not make human expertise obsolete. Judging whether an AI-generated recommendation is sensible can itself require substantial domain knowledge, but it changes where managers add value.

The premium increasingly shifts towards capabilities technology finds much harder to replicate: judgement, trust, coaching, persuasion and resolving disagreement.

The future manager may derive less value from being the person in the room who knows the most and more from creating an environment in which the collective knowledge of the team is used effectively.

Stop making management the prize

Companies therefore need to stop treating management as the inevitable destination for every successful specialist. Asia needs outstanding engineers, researchers, bankers, technologists and other specialists. They should be able to progress in remuneration, status and influence without having to manage a team.

For employees who do want to lead, preparation should begin before promotion. Potential managers should be assessed not only on what they have achieved themselves, but on whether they can develop others, delegate judgement, handle difficult conversations and work across organisational boundaries.

Hays found management positions among the harder categories for employers across Asia to fill. The answer cannot simply be to keep promoting technically accomplished people and hope leadership follows.

The hardest skill is letting go

There is ultimately a psychological challenge behind all of this. Successful professionals spend much of their careers being taught that indispensability is a virtue. Management asks them to reconsider that assumption.

A strong manager should gradually create a team capable of making more decisions without them. Their expertise remains available when genuinely needed, but they no longer sit at the centre of every problem.

This produces an interesting paradox. The manager who repeatedly swoops in to rescue difficult projects may look enormously valuable. The manager whose team rarely needs rescuing may have accomplished considerably more.

As Malaysian and Asian businesses contend with AI, skills shortages and changing employee expectations, companies should therefore ask a different question when deciding whom to promote.

Not simply: Who has proved they are excellent at this job? But: Who can make everyone around them better at theirs? Being the person with all the answers may get someone promoted, learning when not to provide them may be what finally makes them a leader.

Juanita Mega is managing director of The Academy by Intuition.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share