
KUALA LUMPUR (Nov 3): The High Court on Tuesday ordered the federal government to file its reply to the latest suit filed by Semantan Estate (1952) Sdn Bhd last month where it sought to compel the government to sell the Duta enclave land and hand over its proceeds.
Judge Datuk Anand Ponnudurai directed senior federal counsels Nurhafizza Azizan and Shazreen Nadia Zulkipli and federal counsel Nuur Zul Izzati Zulkipli who entered an appearance for the government to file its defence by Jan 4 next year.
The judge ordered Semantan Estate to file its reply by Feb 12, and fixed Feb 16 for the next case management.
Semantan Estate was represented by counsel AG Kalidas and Choo Shi Jin of Messrs AG Kalidas Doris & Nada.
Kalidas, when contacted by The Edge, confirmed the outcome of Tuesday’s case management.
Last month, The Edge reported the third legal action by Semantan Estate and its liquidator seeking to compel the government to sell the 263.272-acre prime Duta enclave land in Kuala Lumpur, and hand over the proceeds to the company, subject to deductions for any compensation received through separate ongoing legal proceedings.
Semantan Estate, which is undergoing voluntary liquidation, and its liquidator Dr Jim Lai Chee Chuen named six defendants, namely the Malaysian government, the Federal Land Commissioner, the Federal Territories minister, the director general of the Department of Lands and Mines, the director of the Federal Territory Land and Mines Department, and the natural resources and environmental sustainability minister.
In the writ and statement of claim filed, the company is seeking a declaration that the government held the said prime land in trust for the company, as well as a court order directing the government to sell or agree to sell the land within a specified period.
Further, it sought any order for the Federal Land Commissioner, as the registered owner, and the other defendants to execute the necessary documents to facilitate the sale as directed by the court, without the land being re-registered to Semantan Estate.
The company is also seeking an acknowledgement that it is entitled to the sale proceeds, less any amounts credited to it through other proceedings.
Alternatively, Semantan Estate wants an equitable compensation or other relief to enforce its rights arising from the government's position as the trustee, including compensation under Article 13 of the Federal Constitution, which protects property rights.
Besides this latest case, the other ongoing suits are firstly the mesne profit suit against the government and secondly the compensation assessment to the company according to the 1956 rate as directed by the Court of Appeal last year.
The hearing for mesne profit has concluded pending a decision before judge Datuk Ahmad Shahrir Mohd Salleh (now a Court of Appeal judge) while the hearing for the 1956 compensation is still ongoing before judge Roslan Mat Nor.