
This article first appeared in Forum, The Edge Malaysia Weekly on October 26, 2026 - November 1, 2026
Corruption and other scandals involving government-linked companies (GLCs) are, unfortunately, not new. Neither are analyses and commentaries that follow. We are never short on prescriptions for how to prevent these scandals. The latest, of course, is the scandal that engulfed Lembaga Tabung Haji.
How about the roles of the accountants and the lawyers, the GLCs’ professional advisers?
In my past role as US legal counsel for several successful GLCs, I saw how Malaysian businesses prized accountants more than lawyers. In several instances, the GLCs actually hired law firms recommended by the accounting firms. That, reader, is the extent of the influence of accounting firms.
Moving forward, I urge the new generation of Malaysian lawyers to be more proactive and assertive. Not easy, but you can create an environment where you can find your voice in the boardroom. You can then help build a corporate culture where corruption and bad governance are things of the past.
Briefly, in Malaysia, external auditors routinely conduct audits that can, at the very least, flag financial irregularities. In the Tabung Haji case, one wonders if effective accounting and auditing controls could have prevented the scandal.
Lawyers, on the other hand, operate somewhat less transparently to the public. In the Tabung Haji case, it would be instructive to know what its legal team did.
GLCs, like most corporations, are served by internal legal teams. During major transactions, external law firms are often brought in to support internal legal managers. However, the effectiveness of these external law firms in preventing malfeasance remains a grey area.
What exactly is the role of these external lawyers? Can they prevent their clients from committing malfeasance?
Consider a hypothetical scenario: A client transfers an unreasonably large sum of money across multiple international banks, ostensibly to purchase real estate at a later date. The law firm puts the money in the client account. Does the handling law firm have a legal or ethical obligation to alert the authorities for a possible money laundering activity?
Confidentiality, attorney-client privileged communication, anti-money laundering obligations and suspicious transaction reporting are all difficult and tricky issues that lawyers have to grapple with.
An article republished in 2018 by Global Witness with the title “What role did US lawyers play in Malaysia’s 1MDB (1Malaysia Development Bhd) scandal?” raised some of these issues.
The involvement of US law firms in the 1MDB saga forces us to examine the accountability of legal professionals closer to home, particularly regarding corruption and illegal activities at GLCs.
As US legal counsel to various GLCs for nearly two decades, I had the privilege of working alongside first-rate and commercially savvy in-house lawyers. Because many of their downstream projects were located in developing countries, these lawyers frequently dealt with foreign officials who had little respect for the rule of law. Yet, not once in my experience did I see my clients even tempted to compromise their principles. (I had previously detailed an instance when a foreign official attempted to extract bribes from my client.)
On the flip side, I have also encountered inexperienced legal managers who were, either by design or inclination, entirely passive. Content with a minimal role, they would happily relinquish responsibility the moment an outside law firm was engaged — effectively reducing their function to that of an email inbox.
There are many reasons for this passivity. In my experience, Malaysian businesses have not always viewed lawyers as central to business strategy; instead, they place a much higher premium on accountants and financial advisers.
Why accountants and their accounting firms seem to command greater respect than lawyers is a subject worthy of further and deep reflection. For present purposes, however, the more urgent and important question is what lawyers should do about it.
As far as Malaysian businesses are concerned, lawyers are simply documenters — albeit very expensive ones — of business decisions that have been decided.
All too often, agreements are signed — usually without a full understanding of the deal terms — with great fanfare, only to be locked away in a safe and treated as a mere formality.
The problem isn’t necessarily that Malaysian lawyers lack legal knowledge. It is that some lawyers have accepted a diminished conception of their own role.
The public trust lawyers to do the right thing, and rightfully so. Lawyers owe clients important duties, including loyalty and confidentiality. However, those duties operate alongside professional, statutory and ethical obligations.
But when neither internal legal teams nor outside counsel warn the management of a possible wrongdoing, a disastrous outcome is likely to occur, leaving the rakyat (the public), the ultimate shareholders, to pay the heavy price.
Needless to say, preventing future corruption scandals at GLCs requires a collective effort from all stakeholders. Fundamentally, taking the Tabung Haji case as an example, the responsibility lies at the very top, at the board of directors and the senior management levels. I am certain, again taking Tabung Haji as an example, that this governance issue is being addressed elsewhere. At least that is my hope.
My interest here is how GLC lawyers can play a role in preventing corruption and other scandals.
The cautionary tale of the US law firms involved in 1MDB shows that standing idly by in the face of colossal corruption can decimate a law firm’s reputation, even where no clear technical violation of law is established.
If Malaysian corporate lawyers feel they cannot do much to deter corrupt practices of their clients, that their roles are overshadowed by the accounting firms, political masters, cronyism or political patronage, here is my advice:
● Master your core knowledge and skills: If you are hired, you must have convinced your employer that you possess the skills stated in your résumé. If your legal knowledge feels shaky or rusty, make an effort to brush it up. A junior lawyer should not shy away from seeking guidance from a senior colleague. Stay invested in your professional growth — with the wealth of free online courses available today, cost is no longer an excuse. A lawyer who doesn’t know the law cannot challenge management.
● Understand the business and related fields: Lawyers are hired to provide legal counsel, but you cannot protect a business you do not understand. If you are advising on the acquisition of a technology company, for example, take the time to educate yourself on intellectual property law and technology licensing. When I once touched on business issues with an old Universiti Malaya law classmate who was a senior partner at a prominent Malaysian law firm, she commented that I behaved “so American”.
● Be assertive and clear in your counsel: Back in the 1990s, I advised a GLC on a dispute with a project consultant. The GLC’s legal manager was taken aback by the “sheer confidence” with which I rendered my legal advice. I found it amusing at the time, but the client’s comment highlighted a cultural difference. I was direct, whereas he was used to the typical Malaysian style of communication — which can be indirect, overly cautious and circular. When I moved to the US to practise law, I had to learn to write like an American lawyer — utilising the active voice, being succinct and eliminating needless words. Today’s corporate executives, even in Malaysia, do not have time for ambiguity. Say what you mean; mean what you say.
● Build networks and support systems: The Malaysian legal community is extremely small. In the era of social media and digital connectivity, word travels fast. If you are treated unfairly for standing your ground, you will find a community of support. Even if a legal recourse isn’t viable in a specific situation, there is immense long-term value in standing up for your principles and maintaining your professional integrity.
Accountants look at the numbers. Lawyers look at the legality and structure of the transaction. Both are necessary.
When a GLC fails, the government may have to intervene with a rescue package. That is what can happen when politics is involved. Because GLCs are government-controlled, it is unrealistic to rid them of politics altogether.
However, I am confident that the new generation of professional advisers, young lawyers in particular, will stand up to political pressure and build a new business culture that all Malaysians can be proud of.
Dr Alima Joned is an adjunct professor at the Faculty of Law, Universiti Malaya
Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.
P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's App Store and Android's Google Play.