
PUTRAJAYA (Oct 26): A three-member Court of Appeal bench has on Monday (Oct 26) granted Global Ikhwan Services and Business Holdings Sdn Bhd (GISBH) additional time to file the index of its record of appeal over its appeal in challenging the Selangor Fatwa Council and the Selangor Islamic Council’s (Mais) fatwa decision that had declared the organisation and its followers as deviants.
COA judges Datuk Mohamed Zaini Mazlan, Datuk Ong Chee Kwan, and Datuk Mohd Radzi Harun unanimously allowed GISBH’s counsel Zulfikri Ulul Azmi’s motion for additional time after admitting their mistake in not abiding by the time frame.
Judge Zaini and Ong reprimanded Zulfikri that these were basic practice directives given to lawyers and they should have known to serve the documents to their opponents.
Zulfikri admitted that this was an oversight on their legal firm and was prepared to pay costs to the Attorney General’s Chambers (AGC), which is appearing for Mais and the Selangor fatwa council.
Senior Federal Counsel Muhammad Salehudin Md Ali, who appeared for the AGC, confirmed with the bench that they had just received the rightful documents, albeit late, and agreed not to oppose GISBH’s extension application, provided costs are paid.
This resulted in Zaini allowing the extension and ordering GISBH to pay RM5,000 in costs to the AGC.
Two years ago, Shah Alam High Court judge S Narkunavathy had allowed the AGC’s preliminary objection to GISBH’s judicial review application against the Selangor Fatwa Council and the Mais fatwa declaration.
Narkunavathy said the matter falls within the Shariah Court’s jurisdiction.
In allowing the preliminary objection, Narkunavathy ruled that the fatwa is not amenable to judicial review as prescribed by Article 121(1A) of the Federal Constitution and hence it is not justiciable.
She said that in the Malaysian legal framework, the separation of jurisdictions between the civil and shariah courts is a fundamental constitutional principle where, under Article 121 (1A) of the Constitution, the civil courts are expressly precluded from exercising jurisdiction over matters that fall within the Shariah Court’s purview.
“The non-interference doctrine is especially critical when a dispute involves the pith and substance of Islamic faith doctrine or hukum syarak. When the court undertakes such a review (of the fatwa), it becomes an arbiter of the Islamic faith, which would constitute a direct usurpation of and encroachment upon the jurisdiction of the shariah courts,” the judge had said.