
KUALA LUMPUR (Sept 24): The Industrial Court earlier this week ordered radio station BFM Media Sdn Bhd to pay former producer and presenter Umapagan Ampikaipakan RM358,400 in compensation and back wages after finding that his 2019 dismissal for purported misconduct was without just cause.
In a 98-page judgement, Industrial Court chairperson Pravin Kaur Jessy said that while the allegations of sexual misconduct against Umapagan were serious, BFM Media did not provide sufficient proof to justify his dismissal.
BFM Media had made several allegations of sexual harassment and misconduct against Umapagan, including sending explicit messages, making inappropriate comments and engaging in unwanted physical contact. Umapagan denied the allegations.
Pravin said an employer must prove misconduct on the balance of probabilities. However, the court found issue with the charges and evidence, including a lack of details such as dates and names, and the absence of original message exchanges.
The court said these shortcomings could affect the fairness of the proceedings.
“This court cannot permit a vague charge to be cured by evidential accretion after the event. The company was required to prove the misconduct as charged, not a general impression that the claimant was tactile or overly familiar,” she said in dismissing the allegations against Umapagan.
“Having considered the evidence in its entirety, the court is driven to one conclusion. The company’s case, though grave in allegation, was not made good in proof. Too many of the allegations were imprecise in formulation, uncertain in attribution, incomplete in documentation and untested in their essential parts.
“Suspicion may have justified inquiry. Concern may have justified caution. But neither suspicion nor concern can take the place of proof. On the evidence before it, the court is not satisfied that the misconduct relied upon has been established on a balance of probabilities,” she said in dismissing the company’s defence.
Umapagan had claimed that his dismissal was without just cause or excuse, was made mala fide (in bad faith), amounted to victimisation and unfair labour practice, and was contrary to equity and good conscience.
BFM Media maintained that the dismissal was justified.
While Umapagan claimed that he had been employed by the station since 2009, BFM Media said he had joined in April 2014.
The company also denied that he had an unblemished record, citing a previous warning over inappropriate communication with an intern. It said two external counsel familiar with Malaysian employment law had conducted an independent investigation and that management had not interfered with it.
Umapagan was dismissed on Jan 4, 2019, after being issued a show-cause letter on Dec 24, 2018.
As reinstatement was not an option, the court accepted 2014 as Umapagan’s employment start date, as admitted by BFM Media.
The court awarded him RM51,200 in compensation in lieu of reinstatement, based on four years of service at one month’s salary of RM12,800 for each completed year.
It also awarded RM307,200 in back wages, based on the maximum 24 months allowed under the Second Schedule of the Industrial Relations Act 1967.