
KUALA LUMPUR (July 9): A parliamentary committee has recommended the government amend its contract with vehicle fleet concessionaire Spanco Sdn Bhd, as well as explore multi-supplier fleet management to be implemented in the future.
The bipartisan Public Accounts Committee (PAC) said the Ministry of Finance (MOF) should ink a supplementary agreement so that monthly lease charges are not imposed on concession vehicles that exceed their lease period but are still in use due to delayed delivery of new vehicles.
“This measure is important to prevent the concession company from continuing to enjoy double profits on vehicles whose original capital costs have already been fully recouped within the first four to five years,” it said in a report released on Thursday.
A total of RM28.79 million in government funds were lost due to this, the committee. A total of 5,323 vehicles had to be leased beyond their original 48- to 60-month lease period due to late delivery of new vehicles.
“This caused the government to continue paying the full fixed monthly lease charges together with the monthly repairs and maintenance charges at the peak rates of the fifth and sixth years (on a step-up basis), which were substantially higher than if the vehicles had been replaced with new vehicles that carry much lower first-year costs,” it explained.
The PAC said the government should also amend the 60-working-day delivery period under existing contract terms so that it aligns with current industry norms and capabilities.
On exploring a multi-supplier solution, the committee said the MOF and the Public Private Partnership Unit should undertake a study to evaluate potential cost savings and service delivery efficiencies of alternative management models, such as a multi-supplier fleet management system, with the existing single-concession model with Spanco that runs until 2037.
“The government should also consider providing several alternative vehicle models for each grade category, operational function and department to reduce the risk of service disruption in the event of an unexpected production discontinuation by a single automotive manufacturer,” it noted.
Another finding of the report was a discrepancy between the original audited estimate penalties of RM54.51 million for delivery delays, and the government’s revised amount of RM18.7 million as jointly verified by ministries and agencies.
The committee’s review found that part of the delays by Spanco were attributable to the government’s own weaknesses in management.
This comprised changes in vehicle model variants, bureaucracy within government agencies, registration of special vehicle number plates, and requirements for the installation of specialised operational recruitment.
This also included unforeseen disasters such as the fire involving a cargo vessel transporting vehicles, which exempted Spanco from being subject to penalties.
Collection of late delivery penalties was also delayed by the government due to communication gaps, confusion over the commencement period for the imposition of penalties, and the MOF's failure to distribute the contract documents to user ministries and agencies.
The PAC recommended the MOF expedite its audit and verification of data on the remaining delays for all ministries and agencies, which involves nearly 3,000 vehicles under the Royal Malaysian Police, and issue a notice of demand on the finalised penalty amount to Spanco.
Spanco manages the government's vehicle fleet under a concession that dates back to 1994. Its initial 25-year contract ended in 2019.
Following an open tender, a joint venture led by Berjaya Corp Bhd (KL:BJCORP) — Cekap Urus Sdn Bhd — secured a letter of intent (LOI) for the concession. Berjaya controls a 51% stake in the JV, Naza owns 29%, and Tunku Tun Aminah Sultan Ibrahim Ismail holds the remaining 20%.
However, the LOI was terminated in 2020, and the new concession — for 15 years, from July 2022 to July 2037 — was re-awarded to Spanco, which signed the contract on Jan 31, 2022.
For more Parliament stories, click here.