Monday 16 Nov 2026
main news image

I HAVE watched the war unfolding in West Asia since late February with a heavy heart. What began as a series of American and Israeli air strikes against Iranian soil has now spread across the region, drawing in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states (Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates) as unwilling hosts to belligerent forces and, in turn, as targets of Iranian retaliation. More than 1,200 Iranians have been killed. Critical infrastructure across the Gulf has been crippled. The United Nations Security Council, once again, has been paralysed by the veto of a major power. And the rest of the world watches, unsure of what to do.

In moments like this, we tend to look to the great powers for solutions. But the great powers are themselves the problem. The very states whose actions ignited this conflict cannot credibly mediate it. The multilateral institutions designed to keep the peace have been rendered ineffective. So where do we turn?

Middle powers, particularly those with credibility across the divide, must step forward not as partisans but as peacemakers. And Malaysia, I am convinced, is uniquely positioned to take on this role. Our geographical distance from the conflict, our genuine neutrality, our lack of vested interests, and the civilisational peace dialogue approach championed by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim give us a rare combination of qualities that few other nations can offer. But we should not act alone. We should invite South Africa and Brazil to join us in a coalition of the committed, a coalition that can offer the parties a dignified way out of war.

The conflict in law and morality

Let us be clear about the nature of this conflict. The military campaign launched by the US and Israel against Iran is not a “pre-emptive action” or a “response to provocation.” It is a flagrant violation of Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter, which prohibits the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity of any state. The Charter allows only two exceptions: 

  1. action authorised by the Security Council, or 
  2. individual or collective self defence against an armed attack. 

Neither applies here. 

No Security Council authorisation exists; indeed, the Council has been prevented from acting. And no armed attack by Iran preceded the strikes of Feb 28.

The attack on Iran’s Natanz nuclear facility, a site operating under the full safeguards of the International Atomic Energy Agency, is particularly troubling. It is not only a violation of Iranian sovereignty but an assault on the global non-proliferation regime. If any state with advanced military capabilities can unilaterally destroy facilities that are under international inspection, then the entire framework of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty is undermined. That is a dangerous precedent for the world, not just for Iran.

From an Islamic ethical perspective, the aggression is equally indefensible. The Qur’anic injunction against transgression, and the prophetic teaching that “no harm shall be inflicted nor reciprocated” establish a clear framework. Self defence is permissible, but aggression is prohibited. The war being waged against Iran is one of aggression, not defence. Any credible effort to end it must begin by naming this reality, not because naming alone resolves conflict, but because durable peace cannot be built on legal and moral equivocation.

Iran’s right to defend itself

In the face of this onslaught, Iran has invoked its inherent right of self-defence under Article 51 of the Charter. Its military responses have been calibrated. Strikes have been directed at military assets of the aggressor nations and, in some cases, at infrastructure in Gulf states used to support the attacks against Iran. Iranian officials have publicly apologised for unintended damage and have repeatedly signalled a willingness to de-escalate if the aggression ceases.

To acknowledge Iran’s right to self-defence is not to endorse every tactic, nor is it to ignore the genuine security concerns of its neighbours. It is to affirm a principle that is foundational to the international order and of existential importance to all developing nations. If the international community permits the US and Israel to attack a sovereign state with impunity, and if that state’s right to defend itself is delegitimised, then no medium or small state can feel secure. The precedent set in this conflict will empower powerful states to violate the sovereignty of weaker ones under the guise of pre-emption.

Malaysia has consistently championed the principle of sovereignty. Our foreign policy has long emphasised non-interference and respect for territorial integrity, values we have upheld both in our Asean commitments and in our independent diplomatic engagements. To apply that principle selectively, to insist on it when our own interests are at stake but to remain silent when it is violated by powerful allies, would be a betrayal of the very foundations of our diplomacy. Any mediation effort we undertake must begin with an unequivocal recognition that Iran’s right to defend itself is not a matter of political sympathy but a matter of international law and fundamental justice.

The Gulf states: Trapped in the middle

If Iran’s position is that of a state exercising its right to self defence, the position of the GCC states is one of profound vulnerability. These countries host American military bases, facilities that have been used to launch attacks on Iran. Under the laws of armed conflict, such bases are legitimate military objectives. The GCC states are therefore caught in a terrible dilemma. Their security partnership with the US has made them targets in a war they did not choose.

This does not absolve them of agency. They have long accommodated the American military presence, and some have actively supported the campaign against Iran through logistical and diplomatic means. Yet it would be both unfair and counterproductive to treat them as co-belligerents in the same sense as the US and Israel. Their interests, in stability, in unimpeded energy exports, in the safety of their citizens, are fundamentally at odds with continued escalation. They have much to gain from a ceasefire and much to lose from a prolonged war.

The Security Council’s adoption of a Bahrain-led resolution condemning Iranian actions in Gulf countries, on the same day that the US vetoed a Russian-led resolution calling for broader de-escalation, illustrates the trap in which the GCC states are ensnared. They are being asked to condemn the consequences of a war while the principal belligerent is shielded from accountability. A genuine peace process must offer them a way out, a mechanism by which they can secure their territories from attack without being forced to choose between their alliance with Washington and their own stability.

Why Malaysia? 

Several states have attempted mediation in this crisis. Türkiye and Qatar have been active, leveraging their relationships with both Iran and the Gulf states, but their regional alignments and proximity to the conflict have sometimes compromised their perceived neutrality. China and Russia have called for de-escalation at the UN, but their great power rivalry with the US makes them unlikely to be accepted as honest brokers by Washington or its allies. The European Union has been marginalised by the transatlantic divide.

Malaysia, I believe, offers something different.

First, we have genuine neutrality and no vested interest in the outcome. We are not a party to the conflict. We maintain diplomatic relations with Iran, close economic partnerships with the GCC states, and a working relationship with the US that has never extended to military participation in its West Asian wars. More importantly, we have no stake in who emerges dominant. We are not competing for regional hegemony. We host no foreign military bases that would be jeopardised by a shift in the regional balance. Our economic interests, while significant, are diversified enough that we can afford to be impartial. This absence of a stake is the foundation of genuine mediation. Parties accept a mediator not because they expect partiality but because they trust the mediator has no reason to favour one side over the other.

Second, we are geographically distant. Malaysia lies more than five thousand kilometres from the Gulf. That distance is a strategic asset. We are perceived neither as a regional rival nor as a neighbour with its own security interests entangled in the conflict. We will not be directly affected by the war’s territorial outcomes, and we carry none of the historical baggage that complicates the credibility of regional actors. In conflict mediation, distance often confers clarity. A mediator who is not emotionally or geopolitically invested can see more clearly the contours of a possible settlement and can offer a neutral space, both literally and metaphorically, for dialogue.

Third, we have the civilisational peace dialogue approach championed by Anwar. This is perhaps Malaysia’s most distinctive contribution to contemporary diplomacy. The civilisational dialogue framework rejects the notion that conflicts are inevitable clashes of cultures, religions, or civilisations. It insists instead that the world’s major civilisational traditions, Islamic, Western, Chinese, Indian, and others, contain within themselves the resources for peaceful co-existence, and that the task of diplomacy is to activate those resources through patient, respectful dialogue. Anwar has articulated this vision for decades. In a recent address he said, “Peace is not the absence of conflict but the presence of justice, and justice can only be achieved when we listen to each other as civilisations, not as adversaries.”

This approach is directly applicable to the Iran-GCC crisis. The conflict is often framed as a sectarian struggle between a Shia-led Iran and Sunni-led Gulf monarchies, a framing that external powers have exploited to deepen divisions. The civilisational dialogue approach would reframe the conflict in terms of shared Islamic values: the Qur’anic imperative to make peace (islah); the prophetic model of negotiation (musyawarah); and the historical tradition of co-existence among Muslim polities of different orientations. By elevating the discourse from geopolitics to civilisational ethics, Malaysia can offer a framework that transcends the current zero sum calculations.

A coalition with South Africa and Brazil

No middle power, however well positioned, can succeed in isolation. The credibility of a mediation effort is enhanced, and its resilience against great power pressure is strengthened, when it is carried out in concert with other respected states from the Global South. That is why I believe Malaysia should actively seek to bring South Africa and Brazil into this initiative as full partners.

South Africa has emerged in recent years as a formidable voice for international law and justice, most notably through its case against Israel at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) concerning the Gaza conflict. Its moral authority on questions of unlawful military aggression is unparalleled among developing nations. Its own history of transitional justice gives it unique insight into the dynamics of conflict resolution. South Africa maintains strong diplomatic relations with both Iran and the Gulf states, and its status as a BRICS member aligns it with the broader coalition of states seeking to reform the multilateral order.

Brazil brings substantial diplomatic heft and a tradition of non-alignment that mirrors our own. As a long-standing advocate for peaceful dispute resolution and a consistent critic of unilateral uses of force, Brazil commands respect across the ideological spectrum. Its extensive diplomatic network in both West Asia and the West, combined with its recent chairmanship of the Group of 20, gives it access to channels that may be closed to other mediators. Brazil’s demographic diversity, including significant Muslim, Arab, and Jewish diasporas, enables it to engage sensitively with the complex identity dimensions of the conflict.

Together with Malaysia, these three countries form a mediating coalition that embodies three essential qualities: geographical representation across Southeast Asia, Africa, and Latin America; legal and moral credibility; and genuine non-alignment. None is a party to the conflict. None has territorial ambitions in West Asia. None hosts foreign military bases that would compromise its impartiality. Their combined weight, economically, diplomatically, and morally, would create a mediating force that even the great powers would find difficult to dismiss.

A way forward

What would such an initiative look like? I propose the following elements:

First, a joint offer of good offices. The prime minister of Malaysia, together with the Presidents of South Africa and Brazil, should formally communicate to the governments of Iran and the GCC states a joint offer to host negotiations in a neutral venue. The offer should explicitly cite our geographical distance from the conflict, our absence of vested interests, and our collective commitment to international law and peaceful dispute resolution as guarantees of impartiality. A joint offer carries greater weight than a unilateral one. It signals to the parties that this is not a one-off gesture but a sustained commitment from a coalition of responsible states.

Second, an Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) emergency session with a civilisational frame. Malaysia should convene an emergency meeting of OIC foreign ministers structured around the theme of Islamic Civilisational Resources for Peace. This would allow the OIC to issue a communiqué that includes an unequivocal call for an immediate ceasefire, affirmation of Iran’s right to self-defence under international law, condemnation of all attacks on civilian infrastructure whether in Iran or in GCC states, a commitment to protect the security of GCC states consistent with respect for Iranian sovereignty, and the establishment of an OIC contact group to support mediation efforts under the rubric of musyawarah. Such a unified position would provide political cover for GCC states to engage in dialogue without being accused of abandoning their allies.

Third, coordination with South Africa and Brazil in a broader coalition. The Malaysia-South Africa-Brazil partnership should serve as the core of a larger coalition of like-minded states, including Türkiye and Qatar, which have mediation experience in West Asia, and other nations that share our commitment to non-alignment. This coalition should anchor its efforts in the civilisational dialogue paradigm, convening not only government representatives but also religious scholars, intellectuals, and civil society leaders from across the Islamic world and beyond. By involving voices from the ulama, academia, and civil society, we can help rebuild the intellectual and moral foundations of Islamic solidarity that have been eroded by decades of proxy warfare.

Fourth, joint engagement with the Security Council grounded in sovereignty. Malaysia, South Africa, and Brazil should coordinate their efforts at the United Nations. South Africa’s experience with the ICJ provides legal expertise. Brazil’s diplomatic network provides reach. Our civilisational dialogue provides a framing that can bridge cultural divides. Together, we should work to table a Security Council resolution that focuses on humanitarian access, protection of civilians, and a structured ceasefire process, while explicitly reaffirming the principle of sovereignty as the basis for any lasting settlement. Even if such a resolution is vetoed, the process of tabling it shapes the diplomatic narrative and exerts pressure on the belligerents.

Fifth, a civilisational dialogue track parallel to official negotiations. In keeping with Anwar’s philosophy, Malaysia should propose the establishment of a parallel track that brings together religious leaders, intellectuals, and cultural figures from Iran, the GCC states, and the broader Islamic world. This track would operate independently of the official political negotiations, creating space for the kind of trust building and narrative transformation that official diplomacy often cannot accommodate. South Africa and Brazil, with their own experiences of transitional justice and multicultural diplomacy, would be ideal partners in convening and facilitating such a track.

Addressing concerns

I anticipate two objections to this proposal. The first is that Malaysia, together with South Africa and Brazil, lacks the diplomatic weight to influence great powers like the US. The second is that such an initiative would risk damaging Malaysia’s relations with the US, our long-standing trading partner.

To the first objection, I would say that diplomatic weight is not solely a function of military or economic power. In peace processes, credibility, neutrality, and persistence often matter more than material leverage. The Philippines peace process succeeded not because Malaysia could compel either side, but because we provided a trusted space for dialogue and remained committed over years. Our geographical distance and absence of vested interest were precisely the qualities that made us acceptable to both parties. By partnering with South Africa and Brazil, we multiply this effect. A coalition of three respected middle powers from three continents is far more difficult to ignore than a single mediator acting alone.

To the second objection, I would note that Malaysia’s relationship with the US has never been one of uncritical alignment. We have consistently differed with Washington on issues ranging from Palestine to the excesses of the war on terror, yet our bilateral relationship has endured. A principled mediation effort, one that seeks to end a war that is destabilising the region and harming American interests, is not an act of hostility towards the US. It is an act of responsible statecraft that even Washington may eventually recognise as being in its own interest.

Moreover, the civilisational dialogue approach explicitly invites the US to engage in a broader conversation about peace and justice, not as a belligerent dictating terms but as a member of the international community with its own civilisational heritage to contribute.

A call to act

The war raging across West Asia is a tragedy of many dimensions. It is a tragedy for the Iranian families who have lost loved ones. It is a tragedy for the Gulf citizens whose water and electricity have been disrupted. It is a tragedy for the broader international community that must bear the economic and security consequences of a protracted conflict. And it is a tragedy for the multilateral system, which has once again been exposed as incapable of restraining the unilateral use of force by powerful states.

But tragedy is not destiny. Wars end not only when one side prevails but when the parties come to believe that a negotiated outcome is preferable to continued fighting. Creating that belief is the work of diplomacy, and it is work for which Malaysia is peculiarly suited.

Our nation has, since independence, aspired to be a voice for the voiceless and a bridge between divided communities. That aspiration has sometimes been dismissed as idealism, but it has yielded tangible results. In the southern Philippines, in our quiet diplomacy on the Korean Peninsula, in our consistent advocacy for justice in Palestine, we have shown that a middle power can make a difference when it acts with principle and persistence. Under Anwar’s leadership, we have added to this legacy a distinctive philosophical framework, civilisational peace dialogue, that offers a way out of the zero sum logic that has entrapped so many mediation efforts.

The moment now calls for that same spirit. To offer ourselves as mediators between Iran and the GCC states is not to overreach but to accept the responsibility that our unique position confers. Our distance from the theatre of conflict, our absence of vested interests, our reputation for neutrality, and our commitment to civilisational dialogue are not incidental features of our foreign policy. They are the very qualities that make us credible. By joining hands with South Africa and Brazil, we can transform that credibility into a coalition of the committed, one that can offer the parties a dignified way out of war and the region a pathway towards lasting peace.

As the Qur’an instructs, “And if two parties among the believers fall to fighting, then make peace between them.” 

The believers in this instance are the nations of the Muslim world, now divided by a war that serves the interests of none. Malaysia can, and must, step forward to make peace. Not because it is easy, but because it is necessary, and because we are equipped to do so in a way few other nations are.

Dr Maszlee Malik is the chairman of the International Institute of Advanced Islamic Studies (IAIS).

      Print
      Text Size
      Share