
PUTRAJAYA (Feb 13) : A three-member Court of Appeal (COA) bench has on Friday dismissed the appeal by Tunku Nashrul Tunku Abaidah, who is Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s senior press secretary, over a defamation suit filed by Anwar’s former aide Muhammed Yusoff Rawther in 2019.
With this, Tunku Nashrul has been asked to pay RM80,000 and also issue an apology to Yusoff within 45 days from today, as this was his final appeal, following the case that originated from the Sessions Court.
Tunku Nashrul had previously obtained a stay from the High Court in order not to issue an apology.
COA judge Datuk Wong Kian Kheong, who led the bench in dismissing the appeal, said the decisions of the Sessions Court and High Court are correct, as they had judicially appreciated the matter at hand.
Wong said what was published and said in Tunku Nashrul’s statement to the press in June 2019 — accusations that alleged that Yusoff had a discipline problem, that he had been sacked, taken drugs, and that he created his own stories — were not supported as there are no police reports on him.
Wong said the statement issued had clearly defamed Yusoff. The court further ruled against the four defences of fair comment, qualified privilege, responsible journalism, and justification that had been pleaded.
“These four defences were also dismissed by the Sessions Court and the High Court.
“As there is no cross-appeal with regard to the quantum of damages which had been reduced by the High Court, the bench finds the sum to be appropriate. Following this, we dismiss the appellant’s (Tunku Nashrul’s) appeal,” the judge said.
Wong, who sat with Datuk Muhammad Firuz Jaffril and Datuk Nadzarin Wok Nordin, also ordered Tunku Nashrul to pay RM30,000 in costs.
Initially, the Shah Alam Sessions Court had found Tunku Nashrul guilty of defamation and had awarded Yusoff damages of RM200,000 in October 2022.
On appeal at the High Court in May 2023, the quantum was reduced to RM80,000 by judge Khadijah Idris.
Yusoff had filed the suit in September 2019, alleging that Tunku Nashrul had damaged his reputation when Tunku Nashrul alleged that he (Yusoff) had a disciplinary problem, took drugs, and that he was sacked when he made allegations that Anwar had sexually assaulted him at his office.
Yusoff has also filed a separate suit against Anwar for the alleged sexual assault, which is pending hearing at the High Court.
Yusoff was represented by M Thayalan and Fathima Mohd Idris from Messrs Thayalan & Associates, while Muhammad Azwar Ab Manab from Messrs Azwar & Partners appeared for Tunku Nashrul.