Monday 23 Nov 2026
main news image

PUTRAJAYA (July 3): In holding Public Bank Bhd (KL:PBBANK) liable for sensitive customer information leak, the Federal Court affirmed that the duty to maintain secrecy extends directly to the bank, rather than just its officers or staff.

Section 97(1) of the now-repealed Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989 spelled out that the legal obligation applies directly to the bank, Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak Datuk Abdul Rahman Sebli noted in his written grounds of judgement in the suit brought by National Feedlot Corporation (NFCorp).

“The argument that the bank’s duty of secrecy under Section 97(1) is not directed at the bank but at its director or officer is misconceived,” he wrote.  

Abdul Rahman highlighted that the first part of Section 97(1) prohibits a director, officer, external bureau, or agent appointed by the bank from undertaking any part of the bank’s business — which had nothing to do with the bank’s duty of secrecy.

However, “it needs to be appreciated that it is the second part” that imposes the duty of secrecy on the bank, Abdul Rahman said.

Exceptions irrelevant

Further, none of the exceptions for disclosure in limited cases under Sections 97(2), 98(1), or 99(1) of the law, then more commonly known as BAFIA, were relevant in this instance, he surmised.

“None of these statutory exceptions apply in favour of Public Bank and none was pleaded in its defence,” Abdul Rahman said. “It must therefore be taken that the breach of Section 97(1) by the bank was without justification.”

Foreign common law exceptions also do not apply when there is existing written law in Malaysia, per Section 3(1) of the Civil Law Act 1956, he added.

Abdul Rahman was part of the unanimous decision with Chief Judge of Malaya Tan Sri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim, who is now assuming the duties of the Chief Justice until the post is filled, and Datuk Abu Bakar Jais in upholding the Court of Appeal’s 2023 finding that the bank violated its statutory and contractual duty of confidentiality under BAFIA.

Two weeks ago, the Federal Court had awarded RM90 million in equitable, exemplary and aggravated damages to NFCorp, and four others including its chairman Datuk Seri Dr Mohamad Salleh Ismail, after dismissing Public Bank’s appeal.

The bench also ordered the bank to pay 2% interest on the total sum effective Wednesday, June 18, until the payment of damages is settled.

Cows-in-condo

The case arose from a press conference held on March 7, 2012 by Datuk Seri Mohd Rafizi Ramli, now an ex-economy minister, during which he disclosed internal banking documents related to a loan application by Mohamad Salleh and his son.

Mohamad Salleh is the husband of Tan Sri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil, Malaysia’s first minister of women, family and community development.

The document, known as Annexure E, outlined a loan assessment for the purchase of condominiums at KL Eco City. Although the loan offer was eventually withdrawn and no loan was executed, the information sparked national controversy and later became known as the cows-in-condos scandal.

In its judgement, the Federal Court firmly rejected Public Bank’s argument that it could not be held responsible for the actions of two employees — Cheam Chen Hooi and Johari Mohamad — who had accessed and leaked the documents without authorisation.

The bank had contended that the employees acted outside the scope of their duties, and thus liability should not be imputed to the institution.

NFCorp’s case

The originating suit in the High Court was filed by NFCorp, Mohamad Salleh, National Meat & Livestock Corporation Sdn Bhd, Agroscience Industries Sdn Bhd, and Real Food Company Sdn Bhd against Public Bank for leaking details of their accounts and the planned purchase at KL Eco City.

The High Court did not find that Public Bank had breached confidentiality.

On Aug 30, 2023, the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court’s decision, finding Public Bank liable for breaching its duty of confidentiality. The court only awarded nominal damages of RM10,000 and ordered Public Bank to pay RM500,000 in costs.

In overturning the decision, the Court of Appeal ruled that the High Court judge had ignored vital evidence from the bank’s domestic inquiry on its former clerk Johari, who was implicated in the leak of confidential documents.

NFCorp then went to the nation’s apex court this year to appeal for more damages, while Public Bank appealed but failed to reverse the decision.

Lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah, representing NFCorp, told the bench previously that his clients were seeking as much as RM560 million in damages: RM60 million in general damages, RM250 million in exemplary damages, and another RM250 million in aggravated damages.

Shafee said that judges at the Court of Appeal and High Court did not consider that his client had suffered serious loss due to the bank’s breach of confidentiality.

Edited ByJason Ng
      Print
      Text Size
      Share