This article first appeared in Forum, The Edge Malaysia Weekly on January 20, 2025 - January 26, 2025

When US president-elect Donald Trump suggested annexing Canada, the world collectively rolled its eyes. Another provocative soundbite from the man who makes headlines with the frequency of a late-night infomercial. But let’s take a step back, forget the knee-jerk outrage, and ask: What if there is more to this than meets the eye? What if this audacious proposition, veiled in bluster, actually contains the seeds of a transformative opportunity — not just for Canada, but as a case study in geopolitical strategy?

This is not just about North America; this is about realpolitik at its finest. History is full of examples where seemingly aggressive moves were flipped into mutually beneficial arrangements. The key is thinking strategically, beyond borders, and acting not as a reactionary but as a global player.

Trump’s rhetoric sounds hostile — annexation is hardly a friendly term — but it is also a negotiation tactic on steroids. Canada, instead of shutting the door outright, could take a lesson from history and turn this moment into a blueprint for a new kind of economic alliance. Forget annexation; think economic union — a partnership where sovereignty is preserved, but mutual gains are maximised.

Consider the European Union (EU). Born out of the rubble of World War II, it started with the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) in 1951. What began as a narrow economic pact between six countries evolved into a sprawling union of 27 member states. The EU is not perfect, but it is a shining example of how integration can boost economies, reduce governance costs and foster regional stability without erasing national identities. Germany did not stop being Germany, Italy still has its pasta and France still protects its cheese. But, collectively, they are stronger, richer and more influential.

Closer to home, the Asean Economic Community offers another model. Southeast Asia’s nations are wildly different in culture, governance and economic development, but Asean has created a framework for cooperation that has enhanced trade and investment across the region. It did not require annexation or loss of sovereignty — just smart, strategic alignment.

The US itself is a historical example of fragmented entities uniting for mutual benefit. The Articles of Confederation, flawed as they were, laid the groundwork for a stronger federal union that propelled the US into becoming a global superpower. Similarly, the Zollverein — Germany’s 19th-century customs union — was the economic glue that predated the unification of German states. It slashed tariffs, boosted trade and set the stage for political unity, all while allowing member states to retain significant autonomy.

In all these cases, the central theme is clear: integration does not mean assimilation. It means crafting alliances that play to collective strengths while preserving individual identities.

For Canada, Trump’s annexation rhetoric should be seen not as a threat, but as an opening gambit in a high-stakes game of chess. A savvy move here could create a unique North American economic union that blends the efficiencies of integration with the cultural and political distinctiveness that Canadians hold dear.

Such a union would not mean sacrificing universal healthcare, regional governance or the poetic solitude of the Canadian wilderness. Instead, it could mean reducing redundancies in governance, enhancing trade efficiencies and amplifying bargaining power on the global stage. Picture a Canada that retains its maple syrup and hockey, while also wielding greater influence in markets from Asia to Europe.

But this is not just about Canada. It is a lesson for nations worldwide. Small- and medium-sized countries often view larger neighbours as existential threats. Yet history shows us that when those smaller nations engage strategically, they can secure deals that strengthen their position. Think of Finland during the Cold War — caught between the Soviet Union and the West, it maintained its independence while fostering economic relationships with both sides. Canada could do the same, positioning itself as an indispensable partner in a reimagined North America.

Here’s the real genius move. Trump’s tendency to shoot from the hip gives Canada — or any strategic nation — the upper hand. His public statements are often traps of his own making. By proposing an economic union on Canada’s terms — one that is heavy on mutual benefits but tilted subtly in its favour — Canada could force Trump into a corner. After all, once he has made a bold declaration, walking it back damages his credibility.

Imagine Canada presenting a polished proposal: reduced trade barriers, streamlined governance and enhanced economic integration, all while ensuring airtight exit clauses and protections for Canadian interests. Trump, eager to claim a “win”, might find himself hard-pressed to refuse. And if he balks? Canada walks away with its dignity intact and the moral high ground firmly in hand.

The lesson here transcends North America. In an era of increasing nationalism and geopolitical tension, the ability to transform confrontation into collaboration is a masterstroke of global strategy. This is not just a Canadian play; it is a universal principle. Whether it is South Korea navigating between China and the US, or smaller EU states balancing against larger powers, the art of turning threats into triumphs is a skill every nation should hone.

As global citizens, we should view moments like these not with fear, but with curiosity. How can nations leverage disruptive rhetoric to craft creative, mutually beneficial solutions? How can we use the lessons of history — of Zollvereins, EU treaties and Asean accords — to inform our future?

Trump’s annexation gambit may be little more than noise, but in the hands of a savvy, strategic partner, it could become a symphony. The key is seeing the opportunity, playing the long game, and ensuring that when the dust settles, the benefits are as sweet as maple syrup — but the deal, naturally, favours the savvy over the loud.

Abbi Kanthasamy (www.abbiphotography.com) is a Canadian entrepreneur, photographer and writer. An avid traveller, his journeys inspire and enrich his photography and writing.

Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.

P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's App Store and Android's Google Play.