Thursday 19 Nov 2026
main news image

Mark Wakeford, CEO of Indofood Agri Resources, knows all too well that some investors are disappointed with his company’s performance recently. Palm oil production growth has been coming in short, largely on poorer output from smallholders who have skimped on fertiliser. The company also faces cut-throat competition in the cooking oil business in Indonesia, even though it holds the No 1 position. And its fledgling sugar business is taking longer than expected to take off. Wakeford isn’t sweating, however.

While palm oil production has been weak, strong demand for the edible oil has kept prices firm at about US$800 (RM2,512) a tonne. That’s easily about 2½ times IndoAgri’s production costs. “As a group, we make most of our profits from plantations, so that’s the real profit driver for us,” Wakeford tells The Edge Singapore in a recent interview. Indeed, more than 90% of the company’s earnings come from its plantations, although a sizeable chunk of its sales comes from its cooking oil business. And IndoAgri is likely to continue growing its CPO production volumes by 5% to 10% a year, Wakeford added. “[That’s] very much driven by the age profile of our trees, plus new matured areas­ coming into production.”

In fact, some analysts have turned more positive on shares in IndoAgri on the view that CPO prices could rise further in coming months. OCBC Investment Research recently raised its CPO price assumptions from an average of US$800 a tonne to US$825 a tonne for FY2010 and US$860 a tonne for FY2011. CPO for January 2011 delivery hit a 26-month high of RM3,348 (US$1,083) intraday before closing at RM3,296 in Kuala Lumpur last Monday, right after Dorab Mistry, a respected industry veteran, repeated his prediction at a conference in China on Nov 7 that the key vegetable oil would surpass RM3,300 a tonne by early next year. Last year, Indo­Agri was selling its CPO at an average of US$683 a tonne.

Shares in IndoAgri have risen about one-fifth this year. And the stock could well be poised to climb higher, according to DBS Vickers analyst Ben Santoso. “We expect the group’s earnings growth to remain one of the highest in the sector over the next three years, due to increased oil palm maturity, initial contribution from sugar and resilient rubber and seeds contribution,” Santoso said in a Nov 1 research note, recommending a “buy” on IndoAgri, with a price target of S$3.05 (RM7.32).
Wakeford: We’re looking to have at least three sugar factories in Indonesia and to grow the business to [eventually] produce at least half a million tonnes of sugar.
That’s giving CEO Wakeford some breathing room to position the company for stronger underlying growth. “We will concentrate our planting expansion on  oil palm and sugar cane,” he said. At the moment, rubber is the company’s second-largest crop by area planted, but sugar will soon overtake it, he added, “[the] reason being the economics for sugar, in terms of cash flow, is a lot quicker”.

Repositioning LonSum
IndoAgri actually produces much more than just palm oil, sugar and rubber. The company also grows tea, cocoa and coconuts. These more exotic crops came with its 2007 acquisition of PT Perusahaan Perkebunan London Sumatra Indonesia (LonSum). Some of its rubber plantations have since been replaced with oil palm trees, and Wakeford said the group’s marginal plantations will be further streamlined where possible to reflect the group’s focus on expanding oil palm and sugar cane planting.

“We’re not looking to [plant more] rubber at the moment, but you can’t automatically assume [we will switch completely] to oil palm… The Sulawesi rubber estates, [for instance], are not suited for oil palm because it is not wet enough there, and the tea plantations are at a high altitude, so the only option is to sell the land to someone else who wants to use it for tea or to continue growing tea there ourselves,” he said.

All in, the group has 21,699ha of rubber plantations — spread across north and south Sumatra, east Kalimantan as well as south Sulawesi — as at Sept 30, down 39ha year-to-date. Some 70% of the rubber trees are between seven and 20 years old, while the rest are relatively young. “Most of the older trees are with LonSum; the younger trees belong to Indo­Agri,” said Wakeford. The group had 4,475ha of immature rubber plantations at end-2009 and sold 16,000 tonnes of rubber for the nine months ended Sept 30.

Getting out of rubber might not sound like a good idea, given that na­tural rubber prices are hitting record highs of over US$4,000 a tonne on growing supply concerns. But Wakeford said IndoAgri’s resources could be better deployed elsewhere now. “Although the fundamentals for natural rubber are [improving] because a lot of the plantations are not expanding in rubber, our view is that we can turn our capital over quicker in palm oil and sugar than we can in rubber,” he said.

While sugar cane begins yielding a year after planting, rubber trees take seven years before their sap can be tapped to produce latex. “Given the long time you have to wait for returns, in essence what you’re doing is you’re betting on the rubber price 10 years from now. Although you can make a strong case on the demand equation, you’ve still got to wait a long time to get your cash back,” Wakeford explains. Moreover, the wider IndoAgri group doesn’t produce downstream rubber products with the output of its seven dry rubber factories in north and south Sumatra, he said. “It’s all sold externally.”

Sugar a sweeter crop
A good price for its surplus rubber plantations might help lower Indo­Agri’s gearing ratio of 56% and strengthen its hand as it ramps up its sugar business. “We’ll need about 50,000ha to 60,000ha of plantable land to get to where we want to be,” Wakeford said. “Java and Sumatra islands have a population of 240 million and consumption is in these two islands.” While IndoAgri has some 316,637ha of unplanted land at the moment, he said flat land is required to accommodate the relatively high degree of mechanisation used in planting and harvesting sugar cane. Now, the group is on the hunt for more land suited for sugar cane planting, pre­ferably in Java and Sumatra, “for the next phase”, he discloses.

IndoAgri kicked off its sugar business in mid-2008 with the acquisition of PT Lajuperdana Indah (LPI) from its parent, the Salim Group. LPI came with 37,500ha of land rights plus a sugar factory in Kabupaten Pati, central Java. The sugar factory is already operating, using cane from smallholders, and is capable of processing 540,000 tonnes of sugar cane a year.

As at end-September, Indo­Agri had completed 10,800ha of sugar cane planting, up 2,128ha from end-2009 and 58% of the 18,600ha it intends to cover by end-2011. “This is Phase 1 for us,” Wakeford said. “We’re looking to have at least three sugar  factories in Indonesia and to grow the business to [eventually] produce at least half a million tonnes of sugar.That’s our short-term goal,” Wakeford said. “To get half a million tonnes, we’re at least five years away.” By year-end, Indo­Agri intends to cover 12,500ha with sugar cane.

The company’s expansion into sugar hasn’t been entirely smooth, though. For one thing, its refinery in Kabupaten Ogan, south Sumatra, wasn’t completed in time to capture this year’s harvest season, which resulted in its sugar cane being sent to third-party plants for processing. The US$118 million (S$151.5 million) plant, with a milling capacity of 8,000 tonnes a day, is now targeted to be up and running when the next harvest starts in April 2011, Wakeford said. Even then, it will take a further two months for full commissioning of the plant. “You need cane to commission the plant,” he explains. “If you can’t complete the plant for this harvest, you naturally need to wait six months until the next harvest.”

In addition, there are significant risks in expanding into sugar. “The capital investment for sugar is much higher upfront [versus oil palm],” said Wakeford. “[It cost us] US$200 million to get an economic plantation size with an economic factory. The factory alone is US$120 million.” By comparison, building a palm oil refining factory doesn’t cost much more than US$10 million, he added. “That may be why other plantation groups in Indonesia haven’t looked at sugar.”

Still, with many plantation companies earning huge margins from producing palm oil, they could be eyeing the sugar sector. Indonesia reportedly plans to grow sugar cane on 500,000ha of land in Merauke, Papua in its effort to become self-sufficient in sugar by 2014. And a number of heavyweight corporate players are heeding the call to get into the sugar business now.

Notably, Wilmar International has received location licence for its planned 200,000ha sugar cane plantation in Papua province’s Tabonji village and is only awaiting forestry permits before commencing test  plantings, said Martua Sitorus, its COO and co-founder. Controlled by Kuok Khoon Hong, a nephew of Asia’s “Sugar King” Robert Kuok, Wilmar has also recently moved to acquire Australia’s Sucrogen, the world’s second-largest raw sugar exporter. In late-August, Wilmar also bought Indonesian sugar refinery PT Jawamanis Rafinasi and Singapore-based trading company Windsor & Brook Trading. Located close to the Ciwandan and Cigading ports in Jawa’s Banten province, Jawamanis can produce 340,000 tonnes of refined sugar a year, according to its website. More importantly, Jawamanis comes with a licence to import sugar.

Indonesian sugar rush
Wakeford said there is room for more players in the sugar business. That’s because Indonesia imports about two million tonnes of sugar a year, about 40% of the five million tonnes of sugar it consumed last year. “To fill that two-million tonne import gap today, you need an investment of at least US$2.6 billion and at least 250,000ha of land, and that shortfall is getting bigger as consumption goes up,” he said. Also, much of the sugar produced in countries like Brazil, currently the largest exporter of the commodity, is being used to produce ethanol. In fact, Wakeford doubts that production will catch up with demand in Indonesia for at least five years.

In the meantime, Indonesia’s price control system that enables smallholders to stay profitable is helping to underwrite the risk faced by the big players as they get into the business now. Sugar currently sells for a minimum of IDR6,350 (92 cents) a kg, or about US$712 a tonne, in Indonesia. “The criterion we had was 15% IRR [internal rate of return] for sugar when we invested, assuming IDR5,000 a kg. We’ll comfortably exceed that,” Wakeford said when asked about profit margins in IndoAgri’s sugar operations.

Interestingly, the Salim Group was once in the sugar business. In 1994, the group’s patriarch Liem Sioe Liong was reportedly planning to team up with Robert Kuok to create one of the largest sugar empires in the world by merging their sugar-related assets in Indonesia and investing US$1 billion on seven projects in south Sumatra that would each produce 120,000 tonnes of sugar a year. Unfortunately, Liem’s Salim Group had to give up its sugar estates when it restructured in the wake of the Asian financial crisis. Besides IndoAgri, the Salim Group’s other major public company is Jakarta-listed PT Indofood Sukses Makmur Tbk, the largest instant-noodle maker in the world.

As IndoAgri now leads Liem’s empire back into the sugar business, the company is already preparing to develop related downstream industries. “We will be looking at entering the branded segment for sugar, maybe next year,” Wakeford said. “If you’re just a pure refiner, the way you make your money is by being very good at trading, not by being good at refining. If you’re into food, the way you make your money is by having good brands and strong strong volume. So, that’s the different competency IndoAgri has.” — The Edge Singapore


This article appeared in The Edge Financial Daily, November 16, 2010.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share