
KUALA LUMPUR: The government has dismissed concerns raised by certain automobile makers, including BMW Malaysia, that the B10 biodiesel blend — a blend of 10% palm-based methyl ester with petroleum diesel — can cause engine damage.
The Ministry of Plantation Industries and Commodities told the digitaledge DAILY in an email response that there are no research reports so far that prove the biofuel has caused negative effects on engines or car components.
It also said the Malaysian Palm Oil Board (MPOB) had been conducting B10 on-the-road field trials since January 2013, involving 25 vehicles from various makes, and no negative effects on engines or car components had been reported to date.
“We acknowledge and welcome all feedback from stakeholders on the use of B10. We have conducted 16 consultations with all stakeholders including automotive manufacturers on the use of B10 since 2013,” the ministry said.
“We have requested evidence from BMW Malaysia to back up their claim. Unless and until the claim is proven, we deem the issue to be specific only to BMW cars,” it added.
The government began implementing the biofuel programme in June 2011, with a mix of 5% palm methyl ester to lend support to palm oil prices and boost crude palm oil (CPO) consumption. It upped the mandate to B7 late last year amid falling CPO prices.
Now, it is targeting to implement the B10 biofuel programme by as early as October to use up about one million tonnes of CPO usage per year. In comparison, some 700,000 tonnes are used per year under the current B7 programme.
However, the issue of engine damage cropped up when BMW Malaysia revealed in June that its tests with B10 worldwide found technical challenges with it, saying that palm’s fatty-acid methyl ester results in the thinning of motor oil.
This leads to oil sludge and reduced lubricity with the risk of severe engine damage, it stated.
Later that same month, several automobile makers and associations also stepped out to voice their concern over the B10 mandate, saying that the biofuel is not suitable for their current diesel engines.
Among the carmakers were Volkswagen Malaysia and Mercedes-Benz Malaysia, though the latter clarified later that its diesel-powered vehicles could accept B10 with no problems.
Meanwhile, the ministry told the digitaledge DAILY there is no noticeable difference in terms of engine efficiency between the usage of B7 and B10.
“As of today, the mileage of each [test] vehicle has reached 50,000km to 100,000km without any problems.
“We have also inspected the engine oil after the recommended service intervals and the quality of the used lubricating oil was found to be within the specifications.
“We wish to highlight that the B10 specifications are within the current diesel standard MS123,” the statement read, but did not specify the definition of the standards it was referring to.
It is learnt from the MPOB, however, that the current biodiesel standard used is MS123:2014, which allows only a maximum blend of 7% palm methyl esther or B7.
Under the 11th Malaysia Plan, the government is targeting to implement the B15 mandate by 2020.
This article first appeared in digitaledge Daily, on September 14, 2015.