Friday 20 Nov 2026
main news image

While fine-wine investments have been a hit in recent years, there are also risks, as investors in Singapore wine-investment firm UAG found out when it went belly-up. What are the risks and how should one invest in this unregulated market?

Surging prices and the prestige associated with fine wines have made wines one of the hottest alternative investments in Asia today. And, wine-investment shops have sprouted in Singapore to cash in on this.

David Yap, a 39-year-old business broker, fumes whenever he gets phone calls from wine-investment-shop salespeople telling him how lucrative this “liquid” alternative asset class can be. “They should just stop bullshitting people,” slams Yap, who lost money in French wines and is currently stuck with 120 bottles of unsold Australian Shiraz. In a recent interview with Personal Wealth, he claims he was sold overpriced wines and left to drink his own investments.

It was a cold-call by a wine broker back in late-2007 that lured him into wine investment. They were pitched to him as recession-proof alternative assets whose prices — dictated by strong demand and limited supply — would climb regardless of the investment climate. Being an “ignorant first-time buyer”, Yap believed the broker, whom he says appeared to be a nice guy. So, he invested S$36,000 (RM115,000) worth of Australian Shiraz with Australian Wine Index (AWI). In 2008, when his broker left the wine investment company for rival Premium Liquid Assets (PLA), which specialises in French wines, Yap was again persuaded to invest further in this asset class. He sank another S$50,000 into Bordeaux wines of the 2006 vintage.

In retrospect, Yap admits he was careless for not doing his homework. A few months after making
his purchases, he discovered he had greatly overpaid for the wines. “I went on the Internet to check the prices and I was horrified to realise that the prices I paid for the wines were 30% to 40% higher compared with their retail prices,” he recalls.

“How could you make money with these wines, which were bought at much-higher prices compared with the market?” asks Yap, who has since divested his French clarets at a 12% loss and is still trying to dispose of the 120 bottles of Australian Shiraz, even at a loss. “There is just no demand for these Australian wines,” he laments.

After countless calls and requests to AWI to sell his wines, Yap says he has given up hope of doing so through the company, which “made no attempt” to sell them. “When you asked AWI to sell [your wines], they would not answer your calls,” he complains.

Andrew Bassett, trading director at AWI, refutes Yap’s claim that the company intentionally ignores clients’ calls. “We have got more than 3,000 clients and we do try our best to service everyone correctly. Every now and then, we may make a few mistakes. But we are not deliberately trying not to speak to people or return their calls,” says Bassett, who asserts that his firm “never” sells overpriced wines to clients. “Especially in Singapore, where things are very transparent, you cannot sell wines that are overpriced,” he tells Personal Wealth.

Last year was a “tough year for everybody”, Bassett reasons. “We have clients who lost a lot of money in financial markets, and a lot of people have put extra pressure on our trading department, which we are trying to beef up at the moment. I am trying to put things right. We are all human and prone to mistakes.”

Investors’ dissatisfaction with wine-investment shops has grown of late in Singapore. In 2009, consumers’ complaints surged more than tenfold to 38 cases from only three in 2008, according to the Consumers Association of Singapore (CASE). “Consumers should be mindful that wine investments are not regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and, therefore, they are not subjected to the stringent requirements imposed on regulated investment companies. As such, the risk can be very high,” says Seah Seng Choon, executive director at CASE.

Although Yap clearly isn’t happy with his brokers, he could at least drink his bottles of unsold Shiraz, which are currently kept in a bonded warehouse under his name. There are other investors here who are in a worse predicament, having lost all their money on schemes that do not give investors ownership of the physical bottles of wines. These are the clients of Universal Assets Group (UAG), which collapsed last year and is being investigated by the Commercial Affairs Department (CAD) of the Singapore Police Force (SPF).

UAG mess
“The case is still under investigation,” says Inspector Ho Ban Hsiung of the SPF who is overseeing the case. Ho and the SPF’s public affairs department declined further comment on the case. The local wine-investment firm, which had a short history of just over five years, was selling “guaranteed buyback” wine-investment portfolios with guaranteed returns of 12% annually, or 6% for a holding period of six months, before it was ordered to be wound up by the High Court on Oct 2, 2009. 

“For me, one of the red flags about UAG’s dodgy business was their ‘guaranteed-return’ wine-investment package,” says Tony Cheong, an ex-client of UAG, who divested his wines with the firm before it went belly-up. “They packaged it in a way that seemed like investors were lending money to UAG for a specific period of time. That got me really worried,” recalls Cheong, who sold his Australian wines back to UAG in 2008 at a 10% loss after “pestering” his brokers for a year to buy them back. “It was a nightmare, as my brokers kept changing,” says Cheong, who had three different brokers servicing his account. “I was actually quite lucky to get out before they collapsed.”

Other UAG investors weren’t so fortunate, and many ended up losing their entire capital. Among them was Lea Chong, one of the whistle-blowers who alerted the authorities on UAG’s activities. Chong had invested in the firm’s buyback scheme but failed to receive payment upon maturity when she sold the wines — a case, or 12 bottles, of 2005 Chateau Haut-Brion, which is a Bordeaux first growth — back to UAG. After two months of chasing UAG for payment, Chong decided to lodge a police report in early-2009. “The police initially classified it as a civil case of breach of contract, hence no action was taken. But I wrote in to CAD directly and got a reply that they would look into this, and that kick-started the [investigative] process,” Chong tells Personal Wealth.

Despite filing claims with the Insolvency & Public Trustee’s Office against UAG last year, the UAG victims have yet to receive any compensation. Many have given up hope of ever recovering their losses, or taking possession of the physical bottles of wine they paid for.

“We did not get a cent back and we never got to see any physical bottles of wine. [The investments were] only in paper and UAG did not purchase the wines even though their salespeople promised at the point of sales that you would get to see your physical bottles of wine for the ‘buyback’ schemes,” says another victim, who only wanted to be known as Albert. He lost S$26,400 after buying a case of Bordeaux first-growth Château Lafite Roths­child of 2005 vintage from UAG. “I made a police report on April 2009 [against UAG], like many others. However, after one year of investigation, nothing progressed. Even though a receiver was appointed, there was no money in the company’s liquidation capital,” he points out.

According to Cheong, who has been in contact with the other affected UAG clients, “there are definitely more than 100 victims”. “The company has since gone bust and all the investors are listed as its creditors because they are either owed physical bottles of wines, or money. It is more of a liquidation process right now and there is nothing much [the investors] can do,” he says.

Lure of fine wines
Without a doubt, the prices of investment-grade wines — particularly the Bordeaux first growths of good vintages — have been on an uptrend over the past five years, spurred by an insatiable demand from affluent Asians, especially the new rich of China, who are developing a taste for the most expensive clarets.

Despite the slump in 2008 and early-2009 on the back of the global financial crisis, the Liv-ex 100 Fine Wine Index, which tracks the prices of 100 investment-grade wines, has rebounded strongly over the past 18 months and is currently back to its peak. This index has more than doubled in value over the past five years and reached its highest level last month, surpassing its 2008 highs.

Surging prices, coupled with the prestige associated with fine wines, have turned these luxurious commodities into one of the hottest alternative investments in Asia today. And, wine-investment shops have sprouted over the past few years in the city-state to cash in on the boom.

“Newcomers have come in and continue [to flock] to Singapore. They have heard that Singapore is among the countries with the highest number of millionaires [among its population],” says Herve Aymond, co-founder and director of Corndale Consultants, which is one of Singapore’s largest and most established fine-wine merchants.

Unlike wine merchants, which promote top-notch clarets for their exquisite taste and rarity, many of these investment companies sell high-quality wines based purely on the potential appreciation of their market value. To make money, they would offload wines that were bought from a cheaper source, at marked-up prices and charge a brokerage fee ranging from 10% to 12% when a client divests his wines though them, according to industry sources.

“Wine brokers always tell investors that when they buy a wine, there would be no commissions charged at that point in time. It is only when they sell the wines that the commissions are charged. That is totally not true. They would incorporate their commissions into the selling prices,” says Yap, who has researched the modus operandi of wine-investment shops in Singapore.

“We marked up with a certain margin. We definitely need to cover our overheads and other expenses. As a company, we need to survive,” reasons Jeffrey Chia, operations director at PLA. So, why would investors buy higher-priced wines from PLA when they could buy the same labels cheaper from retailers or merchants? “It is for our services,” says Chia. “In today’s market, our prices are not the lowest, but that doesn’t mean we are the highest.”

Others firms offering wine-investment portfolios, or “wine funds”, even levy upfront sales charges, annual management fees and performance fees of as high as 20%, just like a hedge fund. Selling wine-investment portfolios “on paper”, rather than physical bottles, is better for these companies as they are not required to deliver any physical wines at all, says Yap.
 
Wine-tasting events
To gain access to potential clients, especially high-net-worth individuals, many of these investment shops would host wine-appreciation classes. Some even partner independent financial advisory (IFA) firms or financial institutions during such events. “When they conduct the wine-appreciation events, they would try to sell you some wines at the same time. They tend to hook the ignorant first-time buyers,” says Yap, who attended several of these events.

That’s how Chong was introduced to a group of UAG brokers. “I went to a wine-appreciation seminar with a friend many years back. After that, various UAG brokers called to introduce the wines they had. [IFA firm] Providend and some other leading corporations also ran workshops with them,” she recalls.

Providend CEO Christopher Tan regrets partnering with UAG for a wine-tasting session that his firm held at the Asian Civilisations Museum on Sept 29, 2006. It was after that event that one of his clients started investing in wines through UAG, which had a swanky office in Suntec City and was promoting wines with expensive glossy brochures. “Of course, we were upset as it was through a client event that UAG knew our clients,” says Tan. “That [single] client settled on his own with UAG and we are not aware of the outcome. If I remember correctly, the main issue was about failure to take delivery of some of the wines the client bought.”

Tan says the main lesson his firm learnt is that in unregulated investments such as wine, “there is no certainty that the institution distributing [the products] is a company that is fit and proper and not a fly-by-night company”.

Yap points out that UAG exploited the unregulated nature of the wine-investment trade by using the “en primeur” route, where investors effectively pre-pay for their wines 12 to 18 months prior to delivery, while the clarets are still in casks.

“Using en primeur was perfect because the wines were still in barrels and yet to be bottled. Everything was done in good faith as the wines were not under the investors’ names,” says Yap, adding that the same bottles of Bordeaux wines could be sold to multiple buyers. “Nothing can stop them from selling the same wine portfolio again and again to investors. That was what happened with UAG,” Yap alleges. In 2009, PLA threatened to take legal action against him for making unflattering remarks about the company on an Internet forum.

“We had to make a police report to state our case. If someone called us a ‘Ponzi scheme’, it would certainly affect us,” says PLA’s Chia. The firm made an official complaint to the police against Yap for remarks he made on an Internet forum last July.

“Yes, they filed a police report against me and they scanned that report and sent it to all their clients. But I didn’t get any lawyer’s letter from PLA,” says Yap, who claims to be a lawyer by training. “But, one thing is certain, I have overpaid for my wines. That part, they can’t deny.”
 
Overpriced wines?
In late-2008, when Yap discovered he had overpaid for his Bordeaux wines bought from PLA, he called his broker to demand his money back. “When I confronted him, he said the wines would appreciate further, adding that wine was an investment that was supposed to be held for the long term.” While Yap agrees that alternative assets such as fine wines should be regarded as long-term investments, he had lost faith in PLA and wanted to end their association.

Yap says he bought a case each of Bordeaux first growths, namely Château Lafite Rothschild for S$13,800 (or S$1,150 per bottle), Margaux for S$13,200 (S$1,100 per bottle) and Haut Brion for S$11,400 (S$950 per bottle) of the 2006 vintage from PLA in November 2008. He also purchased 24 bottles of Château Pavie 2006 for S$10,752 (S$448 per bottle). Based on UK fine-wine online exchange Liv-ex’s November 2008 average values, Lafite Rothschild, Margaux and Haut-Brion of the 2006 vintage were selling at S$10,378, S$10,095, S$9,498 per case respectively, while two cases of 2006 Pavie cost S$7,926 at that time.

Chia of PLA explains that his firm’s 2006 Bordeaux wine prices at that time were “in between the high and low ranges” of the Liv-ex prices. “I don’t feel that we have overcharged clients. All our prices depended on the market value during that time,” he says. Chia adds that Yap signed on the dotted line, indicating he knew all the terms and conditions of his wine purchase. “We didn’t short-change him. He should have done his information-checking at the earlier stage before coming in,” he argues.  “We have creditable and honourable clients of the business society who had the same wines as Mr David Yap. They have not complained of being ripped off by our pricing when we sold the wines,” he reasons.

After unsuccessful attempts to offload his French wines, Yap “pestered” his broker from late-2008 to early-2009. “He kept reassuring me, saying that he could easily find another buyer who would buy at the same price. I said, in that case, I want my money back.”

Finally, after three months, PLA refunded Yap his money less the 12% brokerage fee. “My losses were about S$6,000 and I take that as a tuition fee,” says Yap, who feels divesting the wines was the correct thing to do.  Indeed, if he hadn’t done so, he would be sitting on a paper loss of 34% based on March 2010 Liv-ex prices. His initial investment of S$49,152 would have been worth only S$32,416 as at March.

Chia concedes that all his investors who had bought the 2006 first growths would incur losses if they were to sell their wines today.  “[The slump in the 2006 prices] was because of the economic crisis. No one could foresee that. Even banks closed down. But the market is picking up right now. These wines should see a recovery right now.”

He says PLA investors have made good profits with their Bordeaux 2008 wines. “We have a large pool of investors who have bought en primeur from us, for example, the 2008 [vintage]. Quite a number of them have already traded off their wines and made some good profits.”

Risk factors
It is true that prices of top-notch investment-grade wines generally move up steadily because of their limited supply and increased demand. Over time, as fine wines age, they are consumed by drinkers and that tends to increase the rarity factor, causing prices to go higher. But, as recent price trends show, fine wines, like most other investments, aren’t without risks; nor are they recession-proof. Global recessions and market downturns — like that of 2008 to early-2009 — would have a negative impact on the prices of even the best investment-grade wines.

“The risk [for wines] is the same as for any other investments. The bigger the risk, the higher the potential return. No one should rush into the wine market without carefully considering the costs and inherent illiquidity,” says Ben Fok, CEO of IFA firm Grandtag Financial Consultancy. “Risk management is the most important. While owning the physical ‘blue-chip’ wines can give great returns... the key questions remain ‘what to buy’, ‘where to store the wine’ and, most importantly, ‘how much to pay’,” he adds.

In addition, the high fees and charges associated with wine investing could chip away at a big part of the gains, say financial experts. Furthermore, as wine-investment companies in Singapore are not regulated by the financial authorities, investors are advised to be extra vigilant in their dealings with these firms. “You have to deal with only the serious and most reputable firms that you can trust,” says Aymond of Corndale Consultants. “For physical wines, it is better to keep them under your tight control. Everybody can open a [wine-cellaring] account at the storage facilities under their own name. Why should they go and trust their dealers? Buyers should either take delivery or open an account under their own name.” Professional wine storage and insurance costs are estimated to range from S$36 to S$40 a year for a case of wine.

Seah of CASE concurs: “Consumers should ensure that there are physical bottles of wine stored in the warehouse, and that the company is transferring the title of these products to them when the payment is made. Consumers should also check on other hidden costs, such as warehousing and transport costs, among others, to determine the total [cost of] investment.” On the whole, consumers who are risk-averse should not make wine investments, advises Seah. “Beware of the hype. Get a second opinion if in doubt. Consumers should familiarise themselves with the type of investments in the market to get the best deal for themselves.”

Likewise, investors should compare the prices of wines offered by investment shops with those of wine merchants, retail shops or Internet wine portals, to determine if they are overpaying for their clarets. “Why should any­one buy from them [wine-investment shops] when they can get their wines cheaper from the Internet and have them shipped over?” asks Yap.

Developing a distaste for wines
Indeed, given their bad experiences with brokers and the wine trade, investors such as Chong, Cheong, Albert and Yap tell Personal Wealth they have had enough of this alternative asset class, which has not only incurred losses for them but also caused much frustration and despair. “For sure, I am shunning wines as an investment,” asserts Albert.

Cheong concurs, saying that his “close shave with UAG” has shown him what a bad investment wine could be. The 32-year-old, who works in the technology department of a bank, insists he has washed his hands of wine investment, regardless of how lucrative the potential returns could be. “I will not be held hostage by one of these wine-investment firms ever again,” he declares.

With the UAG scandal, Aymond says wine-investment shops in Singapore are now “feeling the heat” and investors have become more wary. But going forward, he feels local investors could be tempted again. “No matter what advice you give investors, some would be tempted by greed. Are people going to shy away? I suppose some will, but most will not, due to greed. With the recent boom, we will again have nice articles in the media about how good wine is as an alternative asset class,” he adds.

Selling at a loss?
For his part, Yap says he is taking matters into his own hands. His strategy is to set up a website, along with other affected wine investors in Singapore, so they can sell their wines at a discount to retail shops or individual drinkers for their personal consumption. The wine investor tells Personal Wealth he may call this Internet site “wineinvestmentsucks”, which is his Google Mail address.

“I am realistic enough to know that drinkers will not buy the wines at the price we bought at. At most, they would pay the retailers’ price. I will accept the losses and move on. Getting something back is better than nothing,” says Yap, who bought 60 magnum bottles of d’Arenberg The Dead Arm Shiraz 2006 at S$225 each and five cases of Tor­breck Run Rig 2005 at S$375 a bottle from AWI. According to his research, the retail price of a magnum bottle of d’Arenberg The Dead Arm Shiraz 2006 ranges “from S$150 to S$175”, while a normal bottle of Torbreck Run Rig 2005 would cost less than S$250 on average at a retail shop.

Bassett of AWI urges clients to be patient, saying the ideal holding period for investment-grade Australian wines is three to five years. With the recent global recession, that holding period is stretching to about five years, as “the US and European markets have all been knocked out of sync”, he says. “But, after holding Australian investment-grade wines for three to five years, nobody should lose money. I had some clients who made 100% and some who made only 5%. It is very vintage-specific,” says Bassett, adding that AWI has a common agreement with all clients to store their wines for a minimum period of three years.

For sure, there are clients like Yap who want to sell within the three-year period, Bassett says. “There have been a few issues with clients who need to sell, or are in need of money. Some people even want to sell their wines within six months. That makes our job very difficult. We will try to help people who are in dire straits but if we were to accommodate everybody, it will cause tremendous stress on our business. Let’s be fair,” he says.

Yap, however, is sceptical of the suggestion that he should hold on to his Australian Shiraz for a longer period of time. He claims it is a delay tactic. “I have actually met up with some of AWI’s clients who have been holding their unsold wines since 2004. I met them for coffee and they showed me their wine portfolios. They told me AWI has not made any attempt to sell their wines.”

Yap says he is among the minority who dares speak up. Many disgruntled investors are simply too fearful to speak to the media because they do not want to offend their brokers. “They are afraid of getting into the black books of their brokers. They fear their brokers might not help them to sell their wines,” says Yap, who says he is in the midst of commencing legal action against AWI.

He understands that when a client signs the purchase agreement with a wine broker, that person is “basically signing away his legal rights” as the contract clearly states that he has read the terms and conditions and the disclaimers. “So, yes, I may have weak case against them,” he concedes. But, Yap hopes that the lawsuit will create greater awareness about the potential problems in wine investing, as well as spur other investors, who have been suffering in silence, to “step up”. “We should come together collectively,” he says.

Kelvin Tan is section editor for Personal Wealth at The Edge Singapore

This article appeared in Corporate page of The Edge Malaysia, Issue 803, April 26-May 2, 2010
 

      Print
      Text Size
      Share