Wednesday 18 Nov 2026
main news image

INVESTORS looking for regular income from exchange-traded securities have a plethora of choices in the market. One newer class of traded securities in the Singa­pore market available to investors are perpetual bonds.

Unlike more conventional offerings, perpetual bonds have no fixed maturity dates. The issuers of these instruments do not bear a legal obli­gation to redeem these bonds. Instead, there is usually an option for the issuer to redeem the bonds on specific dates, typically five years after issuance of the bonds.

After water solutions provider Hyflux started the ball rolling in April 2011 with an attractive-looking yield of 6% to investors, more companies, including Singapore Post, Hotel Properties and Ezion Holdings, have joined the fray to issue perpetual bonds.

Ezion has issued the highest stated yield of 7.8% in the market. The amount of new issues intensified this year to account for 23.5% of all Singapore dollar-denominated bonds sold since the start of the year to September, according to recent data compiled by Thomson Reuters. Such bonds now have a total outstanding face amount of around S$6.6 billion as at Oct 11.

The rush to issue these instruments caught the eye of financial regulators at the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) earlier this year, when it became concerned that growing numbers of investors were buying these bonds without a full understanding of the unique risks, which set them apart from conventional bonds. The higher potential returns of perpetual bonds come at higher risk because of their equity-like nature. According to Neel Gopalakrishnan, an emerging markets bond analyst with Credit Suisse Private Banking, there are four key risks to be aware of when one is evaluating these bonds: credit, interest rate, coupon deferral and liquidity.

The first risk refers simply to the issuer's ability to pay interest liable on the bonds as well as redeem the principal amount. Investors need to be comfortable with the issuer's financial strength over a very long term because of the unspecified duration of perpetual bonds. For an indication of the issuer's strengths, investors can often turn to the credit ratings assigned by various rating agencies, if the bonds are rated, as is often the case. Higher-rated issues will typically offer a lower yield-to-call than riskier issues, owing to the lower risk of payment default.

Another key risk hinges on the direction of interest rates in the market in which these bonds trade. With their indefinite maturity, this risk is potentially very significant, as it can subject such bonds to substantial losses in their mark-to-market values when interest rates rise. Some of the issued bonds attempt to mitigate this risk through periodic coupon resets (usually every five years) to offer a hedge against rising interest rates. For perpetual bonds without this feature, investors need to be even more aware of the price erosion that can occur to their bond-holdings should interest rates begin to rise.

Coupon-deferral risk refers to the fact that the issuer has the right to exercise the commonly found option written in the covenants of these bonds, to defer any scheduled payments to bond holders. This option is usually written in to protect the issuer, as perpetual bonds are considered subordinate to more conventional senior bonds, which will be in default once an issuer fails to make a scheduled payment. "The bond structure in most cases offers some hedge against this risk by preventing the company from paying equity dividends, as long as the coupons on the perpetual bonds are not paid," says Gopalakrishnan. Any missed coupons are also usually cumulative, meaning that the issuer has the obligation to make it up to investors at a later date.

Finally, there is liquidity risk. According to Gopalakrishnan, investors need to be aware that in periods of global risk aversion, their trading liquidity can become thin and erratic. "These bonds are suitable only if the investor can accept the lack of liquidity in the instrument," he explains. "If the bonds are not called and if there is not enough secondary market liquidity, it may not be easy to exit this investment. Thus, ideally, only surplus cash that an investor does not foresee he will use in the near future may be invested in a perpetual bond."

As a general guide to trading liquidity, an issue size below S$200 million would usually mean there would be thin secondary liquidity. On the other hand, an overly large issue could lead to a supply overhang that could weigh on the bond's price performance.

Finally, Gopalakrishnan has also noted some confusion that has arisen in the market between perpetual bonds and preference shares. "For example, Hyflux has called its perpetual bond a preferred share, although its structure is similar to that of most of the perpetual bonds outstanding," he observes. "The risk-reward profiles of these two instruments would depend on the credit quality of the issuer and the respective structure of the instruments. Both perpetual bonds and preference shares are perpetual capital instruments that are generally subordinate to senior bonds but senior to equity shares."

This story first appeared in The Edge Singapore weekly edition of Oct 15-21, 2012.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share