Thursday 19 Nov 2026
main news image

Main Market-listed Toyo Ink Group Bhd has begun to benefit from several acquisitions it made in 2007 that came with a profit guarantee. Late last month, the company announced a net profit of RM3.9 million on the back of RM25.3 million in revenue for 2QFY2010 ended Sept 30. This marks its best quarterly performance since its listing in November 2003.

For 1H2010, the company raked in about RM4.1 million in net profit from RM45.5 million in sales. In contrast to the corresponding period a year ago, net profit improved by 21.7% despite revenue falling 26.8%. For the six months of FY2010, earnings per share was 9.7 sen, up 13.7% from 8.5 sen a year ago.

Toyo Ink’s net asset per share as at end-September stood at RM1.43, which is marginally lower than its close of RM1.45 last Thursday.

The company’s managing director Steven Song Kok Cheong explains that the stellar results were primarily due to a profit guarantee which kicked in. In a deal that was concluded in August 2007, Toyo Ink had acquired EDM-Tools (M) Sdn Bhd, ELO Dunia Manufacturing (M) Sdn Bhd, Inmac EDM-Tools (M) Sdn Bhd and EDM Tools (Penang) Sdn Bhd.

“The acquisition of EDM was among the reasons for the better showing,” Song tells The Edge.

When Toyo Ink first proposed the acquisitions, it reported to Bursa Malaysia that the companies “shall achieve an aggregate profit after tax of RM4 million each for the first and second guaranteed financial year, commencing from the completion date”.

Future earnings could be boosted by other catalysts as well, such as a plan mooted sometime in 2007 involving a power plant in Vietnam. However, there has been little progress on the plant since then.

Toyo Ink first made an announcement in May 2007 on the building of the power plant and other production activities in Binh Duong, Vietnam. At that time, news reports put the total value of the project at about US$1 billion.

Since then, Toyo Ink has been announcing on a regular basis that there are no updates on its foray into Vietnam. The last such announcement was made in end-November.

To recap, Toyo Ink signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU)  with Power Engineering Consulting Joint Stock Company 2, which is under the Ministry of Industry of Vietnam, in May 2008. The proposal was to develop and expand a framework of cooperation with each other in the interest of fulfilling strategic plans on thermal power projects in southern Vietnam. 

“We started submitting [our proposal] in 2006; subsequently, there was an issue over the supply of gas, so we looked at coal instead. That’s what caused the delay,” says Song.

In end-October 2007, Toyo Ink and its Vietnamese partner Becamex IDC Corp terminated their April 2007 agreement for the leasing of land in Thoi Hoa Industrial Park in Vietnam for the thermal electric gas factory. Becamex gave back Toyo Ink some US$3.1 million.
Back then, Toyo Ink had announced to Bursa that it was “... identifying another piece of land in other locations in the south area of Vietnam, which would be suitable for the development of the electric project by using imported coal and will resubmit our application for consideration by Ministry of Industry and Commerce of Vietnam in due course”.
In its latest annual report, Toyo Ink revealed that it has a three-storey office factory and a single-storey warehouse in Ho Chi Minh City and an industrial building housing a two-storey office, a single-storey factory and a warehouse in Binh Duong province. Collectively, these assets had a net book value of RM7.8 million as at end-March this year.
Song declines to reveal how things are panning out with regard to the power project in Vietnam, except to say, “We will make the relevant disclosures when there is anything to announce.”
However, market sources familiar with the company say the MoU could go into effect in a couple of months. This, however, remains unsubstantiated at press time.

Eng Lian ups its stake
Another interesting development saw property developer Eng Lian Enterprise Sdn Bhd upping its stake in Toyo Ink, and emerging as the single largest shareholder.

Privately held Bukit Asa Sdn Bhd surfaced as a substantial shareholder in Toyo Ink on Nov 23 after acquiring 6.31% equity interest or 2.7 million shares from a Ng Ling Li.

It is not known if Ng is affiliated to the Ng family, which controls Eng Lian.

According to a Bursa announcement, Ng emerged with 2.8 million shares after a placement in March this year. In Toyo Ink’s latest annual report, as at Aug 9, Ng had 6.54% or 2.8 million shares in Toyo Ink.

Ng is a shareholder in Ng Eng Hiam Plantations Sdn Bhd, which is controlled by Eng Lian, which also indirectly controls Bukit Asa.

Now, Eng Lian has a 9.09% direct interest in Toyo Ink and an indirect 6.31% stake held via Bukit Asa, giving it a 15.4% shareholding.

Eng Lian is a renowned property developer that owns prime assets such as the Sri Wangsaria condominium in Bangsar and Bangsar Village, among others.

Song says he does not know why Eng Lian has raised its shareholding in Toyo Ink. “I wouldn’t know; it is a low-key property developer. It acquired some shares in 2003 for investment purposes, and has increased its shareholding since,” he adds.

In Toyo Ink’s annual report for 2004, Eng Lian had slightly less than 4.8% equity interest in Toyo Ink. The company maintained this level of shareholding in 2005 and 2006 but upped its stake to 9.7% in August 2007.

A check with the Companies Commission of Malaysia (CCM) shows that Eng Lian is controlled by The Nehsons Trust Co Bhd (41%), Lu Pat Sdn Bhd (25.2%), Yvonne Po Leng Lam (13.7%), Ng Earn Chin (10.5%), Ng Lu Pat, who possibly controls Lu Pat Sdn Bhd (4.9%) and Aripeka Investments Pte Ltd (4.7%).

According to CCM, as at end-September 2009, Eng Lian had assets of more than RM512 million and posted a profit after tax of RM16.5 million on RM49.2 million in revenue for FY2009 ended March 31.

It is not clear what Eng Lian and its shareholders have up their sleeve, but while they decide, the excitement is mounting at Toyo Ink.



This article appeared in Corporate page of The Edge Malaysia, Issue 785, Dec 14 – 20, 2009.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share