KUALA LUMPUR (Sept 25): The 12th Malaysia Plan (12MP) must introduce a strategic roadmap for a five-year recovery plan which includes structural reforms in government as well as the private sector, says Research for Social Advancement (REFSA).
“The roadmap needs to address issues of low growth and low productivity, low wages, and an unreliable social safety net, just to name a few,” said the think-tank.
“This kind of policy restructuring and alignment needs to be extended to all ministries and their agencies as well as GLICs and GLCs for the ultimate goal of sustainable and inclusive economic growth,” it said.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob will table the 12MP in the Dewan Rakyat on Monday (Sept 27).
In a wishlist for the plan, former International Trade and Industry Minister Dr Ong Kian Ming, together with REFSA economic researchers Frederik Paulus and Jaideep Singh cited eight areas that needed to be looked into.
The eight areas are:
- Build Malaysia back better post-Covid-19. New and smart policies need to be designed by the relevant stakeholders. Any additional regulations vis-à-vis Covid-19 must not put too much financial burden on businesses but instead allow for innovation and creative solutions to be proposed and put in place for each industry.
- Address the issue of foreign labour. We need a clear roadmap. This includes implementing smoother and more transparent processing of applications for foreign workers, the recruitment of foreign workers based on internationally agreed-upon standards, and properly evaluating the number of foreign workers needed by each sector of the economy. At the same time, policies must focus on providing generous incentives, training, and advice for automation, starting with the sectors most dependent on foreign labour.
The goal is eventually to equalise the cost of foreign and Malaysian workers, and increase productivity significantly so that individual wages can rise, in particular for low-paid positions — all without increasing the unit cost of the product or service being produced. - Trigger cleaner and higher growth through a mission-oriented industrial policy. In order to pull Malaysia out of the “middle-income trap”, it is necessary to kick-start new sectors, with higher scope for growth and for productivity improvement. The overarching goal should be to attract global corporations, not just by competing on financial incentives, but also to offer a compelling choice thanks to the depth of skill and expertise that we will have developed in a given area.
To do so, REFSA advocates for a broader industrial policy that builds on the concept of missions, where government convenes all stakeholders in a particular problem to formulate a specific challenge; and by providing “patient-finance” which doesn’t expect short-term return but, instead, eye for emergence of economically viable solutions that can then lead to the development of new sectors and unlock economic growth, through the presence of spillover effects. - Reduce inequality through higher wages and a comprehensive social safety net. REFSA stresses the urgent need to have a comprehensive review of the social safety net in Malaysia. This includes streamlining cash support programmes so that handouts are adapted to recipients’ conditions, expanding unemployment schemes to cover a larger segment of the population, and implementing fair tax burdens.
- Institutional reforms and decentralisation. The pandemic has highlighted that an all-powerful federal government risks running behind the facts with asymmetric policy responses. For instance, measures intended to stop the spread of Covid-19 were usually calibrated to the situation in Selangor and Kuala Lumpur, burdening less affected states with stringent lockdowns, and vice versa.
The federal government should devolve significant authority to the state and local level and empower local government representatives to implement local policies calibrated to their specific conditions, for example to decide on how disbursed grants should be spent. - Reshape and reorganise the healthcare system. Healthcare policies must enable and strengthen collaboration between existing private healthcare sector players and the government. Additionally, the 12MP should outline ways to increase the provision of resources for mental health professionals and the treatment of mental illnesses, which have increased markedly because of the pandemic. E.g. there is scope for collaboration with insurance companies to improve the provision of health coverage so as to lead to better health outcomes and reduce the need for treatment in line with the idea that prevention is better than cure.
- All ministries must embrace digitalisation. A clear roadmap must be presented in the 12MP where all ministries are involved in digitalisation and Industry 4.0-related initiatives. This means embracing and adopting big data analytics (BDA), the internet of things (IoT) and artificial intelligence (AI) in the government's overall growth strategy.
For instance, the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Industries can call for the use of IoT devices to measure soil fertility as well as the acidity or alkalinity of the soil in the agricultural sector. The Ministry of Environment and the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources can call for the use of drone technology to map and monitor rivers to combat pollution, forests to combat illegal logging and factories to combat illegal emissions. The Ministry of Transport can call for the use of BDA and real-time traffic cameras to improve the deployment of tow trucks to traffic accident sites as a means of reducing traffic jams. - Identify new areas of economic growth. The 12MP should be more forward thinking in discussing key megatrends or themes for Malaysia and the region moving forward, such as geopolitics, digitalisation and an ageing population, and how the country intends to prepare for these developments. Ultimately, REFSA believes that behavioural change is an important part of this concept, which requires the state to take the lead in driving innovation in line with the entrepreneurial state.
“While not all of our wishlist items will make their way into the 12MP, it is important to keep discussions on these issues ongoing among policymakers, industry players and other stakeholders,” said Ong, Paulus and Jaideep.
“With more substantive discussions and publications of policy positions and papers, backed up with concrete examples of what works and what does not, especially within the domestic socio-economic-political landscape, we can slowly but surely move forward the policy agenda and increase the likelihood that good policies become part of government policy and are implemented in a transparent and effective manner,” they added.