
KUALA LUMPUR (April 17): The conditional voluntary takeover offer by Lembaga Tabung Angkatan Tentera (LTAT) to acquire the remaining shares in Boustead Holdings Bhd at 85.5 sen per share is "not fair but reasonable", said Kenanga Investment Bank Bhd in an independent advice circular.
The offer is deemed not fair due to Kenanga's evaluation that the offer price represents a discount of 45.3% to 51.7% to the estimated value of Boustead shares of between RM1.563 and RM1.751 share.
Nevertheless, it recommended Boustead shareholders to accept the offer, as it deemed the offer reasonable as the offer price represents a premium of between 15.64 sen (22.39%) and 23.63 sen (38.19%) over the five-day, one-month, three-month, six-month and one-year volume-weighted average price of Boustead shares, up to and including the last trading day, of between 61.87 sen and 69.86 sen, Kenanga IB said in the circular filed with Bursa Malaysia on Monday (April 17).
The investment bank noted that LTAT also does not intend to maintain the listing status of Boustead. “As such, the offeror will not be taking any steps to address any shortfall in the public shareholding spread of Boustead in the event Boustead does not meet the public spread requirement after the closing date,” it said.
The independent adviser said Boustead has confirmed it had not received any competing offer or alternative offer for its securities or its business, assets and liabilities.
“In the absence of a competing/alternative offer, the offer provides an opportunity to the holders to realise their investments in Boustead at the offer price,” it said.
Furthermore, Kenanga said LTAT holds the bulk of the voting shares in Boustead, and as such, any alternative proposal will not be successful unless with its support.
“If the holders wish and if the trading liquidity permits, they may consider disposing of their offer shares in the open market if they are able to obtain a price higher than the offer price, net of transaction costs and assuming that there will not be any revision to the offer price,” it added.
In evaluating the offer, Kenanga said it has taken into consideration the movement of the closing market prices of Boustead shares over the past 12 months.
The research house said the historical trading volume of Boustead shares for the past 12 months from March 2022 up to February 2023 was 15.31% traded over free float.
It said Boustead shares are relatively liquid when compared against the FBM KLCI Index as the average monthly trading liquidity of Boustead shares of approximately 15.31% is higher than the average trading liquidity of the FBM KLCI Index for the past 12 months
Holders may have the opportunity to realise their investment in Boustead in the open market if they do not wish to accept the Offer.
"Further, in view that the offeror holds 74.92% of the total voting shares in Boustead, any alternative proposal will not be successful unless with their support.
"Premised on our analysis, we are of the view that the offer is Reasonable," said Kenanga.
The offer would remain open for acceptance until May 22.
Boustead, in an announcement later on Monday, said LTAT's shareholding in Boustead has risen to 75.05% as at April 13, and as a result, the public shareholding spread of the group is 24.77%.
"Accordingly, Boustead does not comply with the minimum public shareholding spread requirement of 25% pursuant to Paragraph 8.02(1) of the Listing Requirements, which stipulates that a listed issuer must ensure that at least 25% of its total listed shares (excluding treasury shares) are in the hands of public shareholders," the group said.
It noted that the shortfall in the public shareholding spread was a direct consequence of the acquisition of Boustead shares by LTAT from the open market since March 3, and valid acceptances received in relation to the takeover offer.
"The shortfall may increase further in the event the offeror (LTAT) continues to acquire Boustead shares from the open market and additional valid acceptances to be received in relation to the offer until the offer is closed for acceptances on May 22, or at a later date that may be announced," said Boustead.
The group said that since LTAT does not intend to maintain the listing status of Boustead, the offeror will not be taking any steps to address any shortfall in the public shareholding spread of Boustead if the group does not meet the public spread requirement after the closing date.
"If required, the board of directors of Boustead may, together with the offeror, explore various options to rectify the shortfall in the public spread requirement at a later stage after the closing date," the group added.
Boustead shares shed 0.58% or half sen to close at 85.5 sen on Monday, valuing the company at RM1.73 billion.