Saturday 21 Nov 2026
main news image

This article first appeared in The Edge Financial Daily on February 4, 2020 - February 10, 2020

KUALA LUMPUR: The proposed Sarawak Sales Tax Ordinance imposition on Petroliam Nasional Bhd (Petronas) is not permitted by law as the transactions are not sales in the sense required by the constitution, a lawyer submitted yesterday.

Counsel Datuk Malik Imtiaz Sarwar told the High Court in Kuching that the sales tax has to be understood as sale of goods as distinct from excise, import or export duties.

Submitting on the first day of hearing the judicial review filed by Petronas against the state sales tax (SST) imposition, Malik said: “On this basis, Petronas argues that the SST Ordinance sought to impose tax on transactions that are not sales in the sense required by the Federal Constitution.”

“The ordinance also has [an] extra-territorial effect not permitted by law. As such, provisions allowing for this are unconstitutional. Taxes imposed on the basis of this foundation are arbitrary and therefore not valid in law,” he added.

Malik said Petronas recognises that Sarawak can validly impose the SST under the Federal Constitution. However, he added this is subject to conditions and restrictions that narrow it significantly.

“This is to ensure the primacy of the federation over matters of tax is not undermined, and that any such power has to be exercised in a manner that harmonises with the federal power,” he said.

Petronas is seeking orders to quash notices of assessment amounting to RM1.3 billion, issued by the Comptroller of SST Sarawak, and declarations that the Sarawak government is not entitled to impose the SST on petroleum products.

The company is seeking, among others, a declaration of certain sections of the notices as ultra vires to the Federal Constitution and null and void, and also an order of certiorari that the notices dated Aug 28, 2019, Oct 7, 2019 and Nov 13, 2019 issued to Petronas be quashed.

The Sarawak government was represented in court by state Attorney-General (AG) Datuk Talat Mahmood Abdul Rashid and its former AG and counsel Datuk Seri JC Fong.

Petronas further argued that a harmonious interpretation of the relevant constitutional provisions would lead to the conclusion that to preserve the primacy of the federation over matters of tax and to avoid a double taxation only if the power to impose the SST is confined to matters falling within the state legislative list as supplemented for Sabah and Sarawak.

“For this reason, the order made in 2018 classifying petroleum products as taxable goods was not valid,” Malik said.

Even if the legislation and order are valid, Petronas is not a taxable person, as it is involved in selling petroleum products in Sarawak, he said.

The hearing before Justice Azahari Kamal Ramli continues today with the Sarawak government making submissions.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share