
KUALA LUMPUR: Insurance-based claims account for more than half of the disputes brought to the Ombudsman for Financial Services (OFS), the body approved by Bank Negara Malaysia to resolve disputes between consumers and financial service providers (FSPs).
The OFS said 10,323 complaints were received in 2015, of which 6,039 (58.5%) were related to insurance claims and the remaining 4,284 (41.5%) were banking claims.
Motor insurance and life insurance make up the highest number of cases because in essence they touch on the lives of people, said OFS chief executive officer Jeremy Lee.
“Everyone has a car or motorcycle but not all have housing loans. So look at the analogy, things that affect lives in many aspects [could result in disputes],” he told The Edge Financial Daily.
Lee said consumers and FSPs must play their roles responsibly in order to avoid disputes. Many people, he said, fail to read their insurance policies, and problems arise when incidents happen.
“So if you don’t do what you are supposed to do [and] the insurance company repudiates the claim, whose fault is that?” he said.
The OFS, previously known as the Financial Mediation Bureau, is an approved operator of the financial ombudsman scheme under the Financial Services Act 2013 and Islamic Financial Services Act 2013.
The body has resolved 22,763 cases since its inception in 2005, with 25% of the cases settled through mediation. Another 67% were adjudicated while 8% of the cases were withdrawn.
As at June 30, conventional motor insurance claims made up 36% out of 265 outstanding insurance and takaful cases, followed by life insurance claims (21%), takaful motor (14%), general insurance (13%), general (medical) and family takaful (5% each), and general takaful, third-party property damage takaful and motor third-party property damage (2% each).
In the case of banking claims, out of 183 outstanding cases, credit/charge and debit card claims made up 44%, followed up Internet banking (17%), dispensation (14%), unauthorised automated teller machine (10%), contract issues (7%), operational issues (5%), and cash and deposit machine (3%).
In 2015, out of 871 overall insurance disputes recorded, 368 were general motor insurance claims, while 268 cases out of 603 banking cases featured credit/charge and debit card claims.
The OFS has 176 FSPs, including commercial and Islamic banks, development financial institutions, insurance companies, takaful operators, insurance/takaful brokers and financial advisers that fully fund it via a levy contribution and payment of case fees.
The OFS board is chaired by former Federal Court judge Tan Sri James Foong while two ombudsmen preside over cases.
Beginning Oct 1, the OFS can handle disputes for banking and insurance claims up to RM250,000, motor third-party property damage insurance/takaful (RM10,000), and unauthorised transactions through Internet banking, mobile banking or automated teller machine, or unauthorised use of a cheque (RM25,000).
The two-pronged resolution method features the meeting with a case manager, failing which the dispute resolution process by an ombudsman takes place.
Service is provided free of charge to financial complainants, but from Oct 1 next year a one-off fee of RM1,500 (licensed person) would be charged.
In addition, the OFS will charge RM1,000 for stage one (mediation by a case manager) and RM500 for stage two (adjudication by an ombudsman).
Complainants must refer their disputes to the ombudsman within six months of the final decision by the FSP or after 60 days from the date of dispute referred to the FSP.
The OFS is an alternative to legal action, thus complainants are not entitled to lodge a claim on such disputes with other tribunals.
Decisions made by the OFS are based on contract terms, the rule of law, judicial authority, statutory provision, and are binding on the FSP.
“We cannot make a decision just because insurance companies pay us; then we might as well not exist. We exist because of the [strict] terms of reference,” said Lee.
“We are not here to be the champion of the consumer or side [with] the financial service provider. We are in the middle; we work based on documents and evidence,” he added.