Wednesday 18 Nov 2026
main news image

KUALA LUMPUR (March 9): Industry experts have questioned the absence of direct evidence against Sime Darby Plantation Bhd (SDP) on unsubstantiated forced-labour allegations, according to a report by Asia Times today.

The news portal added that pressure is mounting on US officials to provide evidence to support a ban slapped on SDP, one of the world's largest producers of sustainable palm oil, after the US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) issued a Withhold Release Order (WRO) last year following information supplied by anti-trafficking group Liberty Shared.

Accordng to the report, industry experts highlighted the lack of details of interviews with workers the non-governmental organisation had purportedly conducted, as well as dates, names or specific locations to back up its claims.

To recap, on March 1, SDP established an Expert Stakeholder Human Rights Assessment Commission and appointed Impactt Ltd as a third-party assessor to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the group's labour practices across its Malaysian operations.

SDP added that the commission will also comprise a stakeholder consultation panel which will be providing additional views on Impactt's assessment methodology, lending further credibility to the entire process.

The panel also is expected to review whether or not forced labour indicators are detected within the group's operations, and if there are any, to determine how prevalent the issue is, said the group.

"The well-being of our 30,000 workers is of paramount importance to us and thus, our focus is to address the WRO and to understand what the actual allegations against us are, so we can take corrective measures where necessary.

"We are very conscious that it has been nearly a year since the petition was filed, a year during which we could have closed any gaps in the implementation of our policies, had we received the necessary information.

"Thus far, useful information from the actual complainant has not been forthcoming," an SDP representative told Asia Times.

Meanwhile, M R Chandran, a founding member of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil, called the ban "baffling".

"In the case of SDP, many of their mills are certified by the International Sustainability and Carbon Certification, or ISCC, and the group itself has ISO certifications.

"They have multiple certifications and it is puzzling because the allegations indicated that the auditors of all the certifications were not doing their job," he said.

According to the report, while full details of the allegations against SDP have not yet been published by either Liberty Shared or the CBP, the former's petition shared similarities with a report called "Cruel Outcomes" that it published last September, three months before the petition was filed. The report contained a chart of International Labour Organization indicators that also appeared in the petition.

However, while the "Cruel Outcomes" report used this chart to record alleged failures by FGV Holdings Bhd, SDP, IOI Group and Wilmar International Ltd, the petition submitted to the CBP used the same chart to suggest failures by SDP alone.

The CBP has declined to go into specific details of SDP's case, saying that it had "had communications" with representatives of Sime Darby.

At the time of writing, shares of SDP traded two sen or 0.41% higher at RM4.92, giving it a market capitalisation of RM33.8 billion.

Edited ByLam Jian Wyn
      Print
      Text Size
      Share