
This article first appeared in The Edge Malaysia Weekly on March 30, 2020 - April 5, 2020
GIVING borrowers a six-month reprieve on loan repayments is good but banks should go the extra mile by ensuring that the interest on those loans is not compounded during the period, says former banker Datuk Mohd Redza Shah Abdul Wahid.
If interest is compounded — meaning, borrowers are charged interest on the interest that arises in those six months — then repayments may end up more costly for the borrower after the grace period, he notes.
“This won’t be a problem for the Islamic banks because in Islamic finance, financing cost cannot be compounded. It is prohibited under shariah principles,” he tells The Edge.
However, it is different with conventional banks.
“Compounding has been an inherent feature of conventional banks … their systems are such that there would be an automatic compounding of interest. However, given that we operate in a dual system in Malaysia — there is both conventional and Islamic banking — it would be most unfair to conventional borrowers to be treated differently in the same unprecedented scenario,” he observes.
Initially, borrowers were confused over whether their interest would be compounded over the six months but last Wednesday night, HSBC Malaysia started the ball rolling by announcing its decision not to compound the interest on conventional loans during the moratorium period. Profit in Islamic financing would naturally not be compounded.
“This is an extra measure taken by HSBC Malaysia for our retail and SME customers, above and beyond the loans/financing deferment measures announced by Bank Negara Malaysia,” the bank said in a statement.
More banks followed suit and by Friday evening, the list included OCBC Bank (Malaysia) Bhd, RHB Bank Bhd, Malayan Banking Bhd, CIMB Group Holdings Bhd, Public Bank Bhd, AmBank Group, Affin Bank Bhd and Standard Chartered Malaysia.
“The gesture by these banks is most welcomed. More banks will likely follow suit due to peer pressure,” says Mohd Redza. “The main issue for conventional banks is not so much waiving the compounding calculation but getting a systems change, or a tweak in the systems, that can cater for this variation.”
The CEO of Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd for 11 years until he retired last October, Mohd Redza was also president of the Association of Islamic Banking and Financial Institutions Malaysia.
His comments come after Bank Negara instructed banks last week to grant an automatic six-month moratorium on the repayment of all loans — except for credit card balances — to individuals and SMEs, starting April 1.
The move is just one of several measures by Bank Negara to relieve the burden of businesses and households amid the Covid-19 pandemic.
Meanwhile, Mohd Redza says Bank Negara’s recent move to cut the statutory reserve requirement ratio by 100 basis points to 2% in a bid to release more liquidity into the system was “a timely boost” for the industry.
“Stringent lending guidelines may need to be relaxed and government guarantee schemes need to kick in, too. Banks should also not get into a credit squeeze mode,” he suggests. A temporary waiver from MFRS 9 accounting standard requirements would also go a long way, he adds.
Banks were slow
Mohd Redza is unapologetically frank in his observations of the banking industry’s response to the Covid-19 turmoil.
“The banking industry was slow to respond to the crisis. They were probably looking for directions from the regulators, but the regulators allowed them the flexibility to decide on their own, to which their response was individualistic and uncoordinated. A lack of unity was obvious,” he states.
In his opinion, the industry should have moved to act together earlier. “Decisions should have been made unanimously and together,” he says.
Nevertheless, banks have done well to avert any confidence crisis. The virus outbreak was unprecedented and has certainly been a wake-up call for the industry, Mohd Redza observes.
“We do all sorts of scenario testing but we never [anticipated this], so it caught everyone by surprise when it happened,” he remarks. “Banks were slow in segregating teams and operating in different sites, and this was especially so with critical functions like treasury, tellers and trade finance. Work-from-home scenarios were never played out, although banks were prepared with disaster centres.”
But there is no excuse for being ill-prepared, the ex-banker insists, as banks should always be held up to a higher standard.
“The industry, faced with the crisis, did not even know what is essential service. As a result, total banking services were provided in the first few days before the banks realised that it was unnecessary and dangerous to staff and customers,” he says.
To be fair, though, the Association of Banks in Malaysia did announce, just before the Movement Control Order started on March 18, that banks were taking necessary steps to ensure the safety of customers and staff. It also encouraged customers to use other forms of banking services where possible, to limit face-to-face contact.
Meanwhile, Mohd Redza says there needs to be more effort to nudge consumers toward alternative payment services during crises like this. “The DuitNow e-money service has had poor use and has been poorly marketed by Paynet. The QR Pay initiative has also only seen Maybank at the forefront with the other banks lagging behind. A thorough review is needed of the whole e-banking and e-wallet strategy as the Covid-19 pandemic has shown us that cheques, physical currencies and paper-plus-counter services leave customers and bank employees vulnerable.”
Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.
P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's App Store and Android's Google Play.